The Chatham County Sheriff’s Office arrested a second suspect on Thursday in the murder of a 20-year-old Bear Creek native.

According to The Chatham News + Record, the sheriff’s office arrested Apex native Tyree Allsbrook and charged him with felony first degree murder in connection with the murder of Emerson Batsche on May 20.

Allsbrook, 19, faces additional outstanding felony charges in addition to murder, including robbery with a dangerous weapon, possession of a firearm with a defaced serial number and possession with intent to sell and deliver a schedule VI drug.

This is the second arrest in the case regarding Batsche’s death. The sheriff’s office arrested Kenneth Bass Jr. on June 9 for second degree murder charges. Authorities are still searching for Shyquaule Javon Fisher, 25, who is also facing a charge of robbery with a dangerous weapon.

Chatham County Sheriff’s Office deputies responded to a reported shooting at a Bear Creek address after midnight on May 20. Batsche was found dead at his residence off Pittsboro Goldston Road as the result of a shooting.

As of Friday afternoon, there is no bond authorized for Allsbrook’s release.

Photo via WNCT.

Chapelboro.com does not charge subscription fees. You can support local journalism and our mission to serve the community. Contribute today – every single dollar matters.

Related Stories
‹
Husband of Dead Woman Found in Jordan Lake Charged by Chatham County Investigators
The Chatham County Sheriff’s Office said it arrested and charged the husband of a woman found dead in Jordan Lake in August, saying Tuesday he is charged with first degree murder and concealment of an unnatural death. A release from the sheriff’s office identified 34-year-old Omar Matthew Ibrahim Drabick as being in connection to the […]
Chatham County Authorities Ask for Help, Release Forensic Sketch of Homicide Victim in Jordan Lake
The Chatham County Sheriff’s Office is turning to the public for help identifying a woman whose body was found in Jordan Lake on Tuesday — and who investigators say is likely a homicide victim. The sheriff’s office shared on Tuesday that it had pulled a human body from the lake near the Farrington Point Boat […]
Chatham County Fatal Shooting Updated to a Murder; 1 Man Arrested
A New York man faces a charge of first degree murder in Chatham County after a shooting investigation initially reported as “accidental” was ruled a homicide. The Chatham County Sheriff’s Office shared a release on Tuesday saying Oliver Arz, a 47-year-old New York resident, has been arrested and transported to Chatham County in connection to […]
Chatham County Sheriff's Office Charge 2 with Murder
The Orange County Sheriff’s Office arrested Kenneth Bass Jr. on Tuesday. He is being held under a $200,000 secured bond and is scheduled for a first court appearance in Pittsboro on July 20.**** Investigators with the Chatham County Sheriff’s Office charged two men for murder on Monday afternoon and are searching for their whereabouts. A release […]
Chatham County Returns Fifth Positive Rabies Case of 2025 in Skunk
The Chatham County Sheriff's Animal Resource Center alerted the community to the latest positive rabies case: a skunk near Silk Hope.
Chatham County Reports Positive Rabies Case After Fox Bites Resident
A resident suffered a bite from a fox on Tuesday — with the animal later testing positive for rabies, according to Chatham County officials.
Chatham County Man Charged with Multiple Felonies, Including Sexual Exploitation of a Minor
A Chatham County man is being charged with multiple felonies after authorities executed a search warrant at his residence, the Chatham County Sheriff’s Office said Monday. Matthew Ray Brasington, 38, has been arrested in connection with activity on KIK, an online private messaging app. The sheriff’s office says it was first notified of Brasington after […]
Chatham County Sheriff's Office Busts 2 Smoke Shops for Items Over THC Limits
After testing THC-A products purchased at two businesses, the Chatham County Sheriff's Office announced charges against the operators.
Chatham County Holds Simulated Active Shooter Drill Ahead of Back to School
As Chatham County’s schools are preparing for the start of classes, the local sheriff’s office is working to make schools safer. 
Chatham County Sheriff: Unoccupied Vehicle Pulled from Jordan Lake
The Chatham County Sheriff’s Office assisted in pulling a submerged vehicle from Jordan Lake Friday morning. The sheriff’s office says they were alerted to the vehicle by a fisherman who spotted it with sonar earlier in the week. The car was located under the U.S. Highway 64 bridge beneath roughly 30 feet of water. Deputies […]
›