Four North Carolina voters can pursue their libel lawsuit against allies of former Gov. Pat McCrory and a Virginia law firm that tried to help the Republican politician’s unsuccessful effort to disqualify votes and win re-election in 2016, attorneys learned Tuesday.

Superior Court Judge Allen Baddour notified attorneys he’s decided to allow the four plaintiffs to continue their claims against the Pat McCrory Committee Legal Defense Fund, the Holtzman Vogel Josefiak Torchinsky law firm and four of the Warrenton, Virginia-based firm’s attorneys. The McCrory allies helped mount a last-ditch effort to sway a close election for governor by accusing voters in 52 counties of double voting and other misdeeds.

The voters from Guilford and Brunswick counties sued after being falsely accused of felony voting crimes like casting ballots in multiple states.

Plaintiffs’ attorneys had sought last fall to expand their lawsuit to include “all North Carolina voters falsely accused by defendants of committing felony voter fraud in connection with the 2016 general election.” But Baddour decided only the individual voters could advance.

“We are gratified that the court has recognized that falsely accused North Carolina voters have the right to move forward to seek redress from political committees and lawyers who would seek to manipulate the voting process in our state,” attorney Press Millen said in an email.

The case may be among the first voter defamation cases of its kind, election law experts said when the case was filed last year. McCrory fund attorney Philip Isley said last month that he hasn’t found a similar class-action lawsuit by voters alleging they were defamed anywhere in the country.

Isley declined comment on Baddour’s decision. Attorneys for Holtzman Vogel and its four attorneys involved in the voter challenges did not respond to a request for comment.

The lawsuit contends the McCrory allies should be punished for wrongly accusing the plaintiffs of felony voting crimes. The Holtzman Vogel firm helped the McCrory postelection effort and prepared most of the voter challenges filed in the name of local residents, the suing voters contend.

Virtually all the Republican-sponsored challenges to the voters’ qualifications were rejected by the GOP-controlled state elections board a week after McCrory asked for a statewide recount, citing “serious concerns of potential voter fraud emerging across the state.” McCrory continued the failed effort to overcome an Election Day deficit at the polls for nearly a month before conceding to Democratic Gov. Roy Cooper.

Related Stories
‹
DA Says Libel Case Against N. Carolina Attorney General Over
Written by GARY D. ROBERTSON A North Carolina prosecutor said Thursday that campaign-related charges won’t be pursued further against Attorney General Josh Stein or his aides, one day after an appeals court ruled the political libel law her office was seeking to enforce is most likely unconstitutional. Wake County District Attorney Lorrin Freeman said that the ongoing […]
Appeals Panel Blocks Law’s Use in NC Campaign Ad Prosecution
Written by GARY D. ROBERTSON A federal appeals court on Tuesday blocked a local North Carolina district attorney from prosecuting state Attorney General Josh Stein or anyone else for his 2020 campaign ad through a criminal libel law. The majority of a three-judge panel of the 4th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals in Richmond, Virginia, […]
Deficient NC Absentee Ballots Frozen Pending Further Rulings
A lawyer for North Carolina’s State Board of Elections said Friday that time is running out to process 10,000 absentee ballots with incomplete witness information and other errors after state and federal judges put additional freezes on the process. Counties had already been under instructions issued Oct. 4 by the state elections board to set […]
New NC Campaign Spending Rule Ends Practice Sen. Berger Used
North Carolina legislators can no longer spend campaign committee dollars toward buying or renting homes or condos that they or family members own — a practice that powerful state Senate leader Phil Berger used for years. An administrative rule from the State Board of Elections that took effect this month bars such transactions for all state candidates […]
2020 Orange County Election Results
Super Tuesday is here and Orange County election results can be found online at Chapelboro.com and live on 97.9 The Hill WCHL.
N Carolina Legislative Districts Set for 2020 as Appeal Ends
North Carolina’s legislative districts are set for the 2020 elections after the state Supreme Court refused on Friday to fast-track a redistricting appeal. That decision led the plaintiffs who successfully sued based on partisan bias claims to end their legal challenges. The state’s highest court denied the request by Common Cause and state Democrats to step in […]
Trump's North Carolina Rally to be a Test for his Clout, GOP
President Donald Trump’s rally in North Carolina will serve as a measure of his clout in trying to elect a Republican to the House in a closely watched special election that’s seen as a tossup race. It will be his first campaign rally since a tough end of summer that saw slipping poll numbers, warning signs of […]
North Carolina GOP Rep. Grange Enters 2020 Governor's Race
A North Carolina state legislator entered the 2020 Republican gubernatorial race Thursday, a decision that denies Lt. Gov. Dan Forest a cleared path to the GOP nomination after preparing for years for a bid. State Rep. Holly Grange of Wilmington announced her candidacy in a campaign video that highlighted her as one of the first female West […]
Feds to Test North Carolina Election Computers for Hacking
More than two years after North Carolina check-in software failed on Election Day, federal authorities will finally examine equipment from a company targeted by Russian military hackers to determine if intentional tampering aimed at disrupting voting occurred. The U.S. Department of Homeland Security analysis of laptops used in Durham County is the first known federal […]
Democrat McCready Says He's Running in New House Election
Democrat Dan McCready said Friday that he’s running, again, for the country’s last vacant congressional seat now that North Carolina has ordered a new election. McCready told supporters Friday at a brewery in Waxhaw, near Charlotte: “I am running in the special election to represent the people of the 9th District.” McCready trailed Republican Mark […]
›