A three-car crash north of Hillsborough on Saturday afternoon killed three people and injured a fourth, with law enforcement charging a man with an extensive history of drunk driving convictions for the incident.

Reports of a crash came around 3 p.m. along North Carolina Highway 57 near Phelps Road. The Orange County Sheriff’s Office shared on Facebook Saturday that its deputies were assisting with the response and a closure between Phelps Road and Rocky Lane was to last for an “extended” period, which was ultimately four hours.

The driver charged in the case is 33-year-old Carlos Gerardo Gonzalez-Mejia, a Person County resident, who made his first court appearance on Monday morning. During that, prosecutors presented facts that included witnesses seeing Gonzalez-Mejia’s vehicle traveling northbound at an “excessive rate of speed” and potentially more than 100 mph when he illegally passed a vehicle on the highway. After re-entering the lane, Gonzalez-Mejia rear-ended a car and sent that vehicle into the opposite lane — where it was t-boned by a vehicle headed south.

Orange County prosecutors said as a result of the crash, 45-year-old Bertha Alicia Vacio-Moreno and two passengers — a 14-year-old and a 7-year-old — of the vehicle struck by Gonzalez-Mejia died. The driver of the third vehicle, a 74-year-old man from Hurdle Mills, also suffered life-threatening injuries from the crash and was transported to Duke Hospitals.

When law enforcement encountered Gonzalez-Mejia after the crash, the prosecution reported in the virtual hearing, Gonzalez-Mejia smelled strongly of alcohol and had “so many open containers that [law enforcement] did not try to count.” At the time, he admitted to drinking and driving.

Gonzalez-Mejia is charged with the following, according to the district attorney’s office: three counts of second degree murder without regard, two counts of felony serious injury by vehicle, habitual impaired driving, felony hit and run, driving while license revoked, reckless driving, DWI, failure to reduce speed, and possession of an open container.

As laid out by prosecutors on Monday, Gonzalez-Mejia had his license suspended for a litany of offenses. He has four prior DWI convictions: one in Durham County from 2016, one in Person County from 2019, one in Orange County from 2020, and an out-of-state conviction from Georgia in 2022. Additionally, prosecutors said Gonzalez-Mejia faces a fifth impaired driving charge in Montana stemming from a 2023 arrest.

Orange County Judge Joal Broun set Gonzalez-Mejia’s bond at $3 million during his first appearance on Monday morning. His next court appearance on the charges is tentatively set for Jan. 16.

The North Carolina Highway Patrol, which was the investigating agency, confirmed the details in its own release on Monday. The alert said the crash is still under investigation.

Chapelboro.com does not charge subscription fees, and you can directly support our efforts in local journalism here. Want more of what you see on Chapelboro? Let us bring free local news and community information to you by signing up for our newsletter.

Related Stories
‹
Police: Hillsborough Woman Dies After Car Wreck Along I-85 in Durham
Durham Police are investigating a fatal crash that happened near the I-85 and U.S. 15-501 exchange and killed 39-year-old Claudia Lopez.
Highway Patrol: 1 Dead After 53-Vehicle Crash on Snowy I-40 in Orange County
A major pile-up of vehicles on Interstate 40 in Orange County Wednesday afternoon left one person dead and several others injured, according to emergency services.
Durham Police Charge Hillsborough Man in Fatal I-85 Crash
Police said a crash along Interstate 85 near the Orange County line led to the death of a Durham man and charges for a Hillsborough resident.
Former Burwell School Director Charged with Embezzlement
Hillsborough police charged a former executive director for the historic Burwell School site with felony embezzlement on Thursday. This comes after the site was under investigation earlier in October over discrepancies previously found in its financial reports. Ronda Tucker of Hillsborough is accused of spending nearly $175,000 on various personal goods and services since 2016. […]
Kania Indicted on All Charges in Connection with Wrong-Way Crash
An Orange County Grand Jury has returned a true bill of indictment on all charges and one aggravating factor against 20-year-old Chandler Kania, according to the Orange County District Attorney’s Office. Kania is charged with three counts of second-degree murder, among other charges, in connection with a wrong-way crash on I-85 where three people were […]
Orange County Public Transportation Piloting Fare-Free Model in 2026
Orange County Public Transportation will be piloting a one-year, fare-free model for its fixed-route transit services beginning Jan. 2, 2026. The Orange County Board of Commissioners approved the move at its Dec. 9 meeting. In a press release, the county government hailed the move as “an important step in testing strategies to expand mobility, promote […]
Orange County Communities to Interrupt Services for December Holidays (2025)
Communities around Orange County will interrupt their normal service schedules during the upcoming winter holidays. Here’s what customers can expect: Town of Chapel Hill Town of Chapel Hill government offices will be closed from Wednesday, Dec. 24 through Friday, Dec. 26. Residential trash collection will not be affected. Yard trimmings will not be collected on […]
Orange County Sheriff's Office Details String of Break-Ins, Larceny Charges Against 2 Teenagers
The Orange County Sheriff's Office formally announced criminal charges against a pair of 18-year-olds for a string of break-ins in November.
Orange County Board Makes CITEL Deal Official, Offers Tax Incentives
The Orange County Board of Commissioners passed an agreement with CITEL to move its American manufacturing operations to Hillsborough.
Thanksgiving Holiday to Affect Local Government Services in Orange County (2025)
Thanksgiving will fall on Thursday, November 27 this year, and the holiday will affect several local government services around the Orange County community. Here’s a rundown of what residents can expect: Town of Chapel Hill Thursday, November 27 and Friday, November 28 are both town holidays. Residential trash collection will not be affected. However, there […]
›