On Monday, the United States Supreme Court has ended a years-long legal battle, ensuring that UNC must turn over records of sexual misconduct to the public.

In 2016, four news organizations — The Daily Tar Heel, The Charlotte Observer, The Herald-Sun of Durham and WRAL’s Capitol Broadcasting — filed a suit after UNC refused public records requests for the names, offenses and punishments for students found responsible for sexual misconduct.

According to WRAL, on Monday the U.S. Supreme Court denied a request by the university system to hear its appeal to overturn a ruling by the state supreme court.

Back in May, the N.C. Supreme Court ruled that UNC must release disciplinary records of students who violated the school’s sexual assault policies.

In a 4-3 vote, the court said UNC must release certain records that it believed were protected by the federal Family Educational Rights and Privacy Act (FERPA). UNC “must comply with the North Carolina Public Records Act and allow plaintiffs to have access to the name of the student, the violation committed, and any sanction imposed by the University on that student in response to plaintiffs’ records request,” the court ruled.

In a petition to the U.S. Supreme Court in September, attorneys for the university and the state Department of Justice argued that a federal law protecting the privacy of educational records gives UNC broad discretion over whether to release disciplinary records related to sexual assault.

School officials have argued for years that they have exercised the discretion granted by FERPA to protect victims and the confidentiality of the Title IX process. The University has maintained that releasing names would discourage victims and witnesses from coming forward.

“We respect but are disappointed with the U.S. Supreme Court’s decision to deny the University’s request to review the North Carolina Supreme Court’s ruling in the Daily Tar Heel records case,” Vice Chancellor for University Communications, Joel Curran, said in a statement on Monday. “We stand by our belief in the importance of a confidential process for everyone involved, one that protects the identities of sexual assault victims. Since the North Carolina Supreme Court ruling in May, the University has fully complied with the court’s direction.”

After the N.C. Supreme Court ruling, UNC released records of its sexual assault cases since 2007 in August. The records show 15 people were found in violation of University policy on assault. Two of them were expelled and the others suspended, among other sanctions.

UNC’s handling of sexual assault and harassment cases has been under scrutiny for years. In 2013, five women filed a complaint alleging the university mishandled cases and mistreated sexual assault victims. The action sparked a review from the U.S. Department of Education, which found in 2017 the university failed in its reports of campus crimes “in numerous and serious ways.” UNC also failed to comply with the Clery Act’s sexual assault prevention, response, and disciplinary requirements.

The U.S. Supreme Court’s decision not to hear the university’s appeal brings this case to a close and ensures that public documents of this kind must be released to the media and the public.​

Chapelboro.com does not charge subscription fees. You can support local journalism and our mission to serve the community. Contribute today – every single dollar matters.

Related Stories
‹
UNC Chancellor Speaks on Admissions Changes, New Financial Aid Plan Ahead of 2023-24 Classes
UNC officially opened up its doors to students who are living on campus this week, as it welcomes undergraduates back ahead of the start of classes on Monday. While the past academic year went relatively smoothly for the student body – compared to recent examples of Silent Sam controversies and the COVID-19 pandemic […]
UNC Trustees Talk Affirmative Action, Accessibility at First Meeting of 2023-24
UNC Board of Trustees officially barred use of 'race, sex, color or ethnicity' in admissions, complying with Supreme Court case decision.
UNC Announces Plans of 'Free Tuition' for Certain Undergraduate Students
UNC’s flagship campus announced another step to improve affordability and access to North Carolinians, sharing plans to provide free tuition and fees to certain undergraduate students beginning in 2024. UNC Chancellor Kevin Guskiewicz sent a message to the campus community on Friday afternoon, saying students from North Carolina whose families make less than $80,000 a […]
UNC Organizations Plan to Still Champion Diversity in Wake of SCOTUS Ruling
Some UNC students and faculty groups say they will continue to push for diversity on campus despite the ruling against affirmative action.
Activists Spurred by Affirmative Action Ruling Sue Harvard Over Legacy Admissions
Written by COLLIN BINKLEY A civil rights group is challenging legacy admissions at Harvard University, saying the practice discriminates against students of color by giving an unfair boost to the mostly white children of alumni. It’s the latest effort in a growing push against legacy admissions, the practice of giving admissions priority to the children […]
Supreme Court Rules in UNC's Case Over Affirmative Action, Ends Race Consideration in Admissions
The U.S. Supreme Court announced its ruling in Students for Fair Admissions v. the University of North Carolina on Thursday, effectively ending decades of the practice of affirmative action in college admissions and a nearly ten-year lawsuit against the Chapel Hill school. The court’s conservative majority led the ruling that UNC’s, and Harvard’s in a […]
As Supreme Court Considers Affirmative Action, Colleges See Few Other Ways to Diversity Goals
Written by COLLIN BINKLEY As an alternative to affirmative action, colleges from California to Florida have tried a range of strategies to achieve the diversity they say is essential to their campuses. Many have given greater preference to low-income families. Others started admitting top students from every community in their state. But after years of […]
Low-Hanging Fruit: UNC Students Bring Awareness to Sexual Violence on Campus
Fruit,” an art display at UNC last month, was meant to bring awareness to sexual violence on campus — a known, and growing, epidemic.
Supreme Court Holds Arguments in UNC Admissions Trial; Chancellor Proud of 'Strong Case'
UNC has maintained its argument that consideration of race in admissions promotes diversity and is better for its campus at large.
UNC Police Investigating Sexual Assault Report in Residence Hall
Editor’s Note: The following story contains mention of sexual assault that may be disturbing to some readers. The UNC Police Department is investigating a report of sexual assault, where an unidentified person purportedly followed a student into their dorm room. The university shared an Alert Carolina message on Saturday at 10:47 p.m. to inform the […]
›