The University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill must release disciplinary records of students who violated the school’s sexual assault policies, the N.C. Supreme Court ruled Friday.

The 4-3 ruling reaffirmed a state Court of Appeals ruling in 2018, news outlets reported.

UNC-Chapel Hill was sued by a media coalition of Capitol Broadcasting Co., the Durham Herald Co., and the school’s student newspaper, The Daily Tar Heel. In September 2016, the group requested documents under the North Carolina Public Records Act connected with anyone found responsible for rape, sexual assault and other sexual misconduct by the UNC-Chapel Hill’s disciplinary bodies.

The university denied that request, setting off a legal battle that stretched over three years. University officials argued the records were protected by the Federal Education Rights and Privacy Act, which shields academic records from public disclosure.

The two sides argued over whether the state’s records law, which grants broad access to government documents, overrides FERPA — a federal statute designed to protect the privacy of students. Language in the federal law specifically calls out records related to violent and sexual crimes, saying universities may disclose three specific bits of information: the student’s name, the violation committed and any sanctions imposed on the students.

In May 2017, Orange County Superior Court Judge Allen Baddour ruled that FERPA preempts the public records law, which would mandate it in every case.

School officials have argued for years that they exercised the discretion granted by FERPA to protect victims and the confidentiality of the Title IX process. Writing for the majority, Associate Justice Michael Morgan concluded that UNC-Chapel Hill officials do not have that discretion in light of the state law requiring release of the records.

“Accordingly, as an agency of the state, UNC-CH must comply with the North Carolina Public Records Act and allow plaintiffs to have access to the name of the student, the violation committed, and any sanction imposed,” Morgan wrote.

Writing for the dissent, Associate Justice Mark Davis accused his colleagues of going “astray” with a “basic error that infects the majority’s entire analysis.”

“In doing so, the majority turns the preemption analysis on its head. It simply makes no sense to examine a provision of state law to determine whether Congress has conferred discretion upon universities,” Davis wrote.

The school expressed disappointment with the ruling.

“We respect the court’s deliberations and appreciate the opportunity to be heard during the appeals process. We are carefully reviewing the decision,” Joel Curran, UNC-Chapel Hill’s vice chancellor of communications, said in an email sent to WRAL.

Related Stories
‹
North Carolina Judge Challenging Outcome of Race Wore Confederate Uniform in College Photo
North Carolina judge and state Supreme Court candidate Jefferson Griffin posed in Confederate military garb while attending UNC in the 2000s.
Survey: A Third of UNC Female Undergraduate Students Have Been Sexually Assaulted
UNC released a report Tuesday that showed one in three female undergraduate students at the school have experienced some form of sexual assault, according to a recent survey. The Association of American Universities conducted the survey in the spring of 2019 and found 35 percent of women undergraduates at UNC have experienced some form of unwanted […]
97.9 The Hill WCHL to Remain the Flagship Station for Tar Heel Sports
The Hill WCHL has signed a new four-year contract with Learfield which will keep it as the flagship station for Tar Heel sports.
UNC Baseball in the 2025 NCAA Regionals: How to Watch, Cord-Cutting Options and Start Times
It’s down to one game for the Diamond Heels, who fell to Oklahoma 9-5 in Sunday’s regional final – setting up a winner-take-all showdown with the Sooners on Monday, with the winner advancing to the NCAA Super Regional. If you aren’t making it out to the ballpark for UNC’s games, here’s how to follow along […]
Bill Belichick at UNC: The Full Timeline
Bill Belichick’s tenure as the UNC head football coach has been full of twists and turns since his shocking hiring to lead the program in Dec. 2024. Since arriving in Chapel Hill, the six-time Super Bowl winning head coach has attracted national attention — for both Carolina’s on-field prospects and headlines around his book tour […]
UNC Men's Basketball Lands Key International Player for 2025-26 Roster
Luka Bogavac — a 21-year-old, 6-foot-5 guard playing in Europe — committed to head coach Hubert Davis and UNC on Saturday.
Here's a List of Every Transfer to Join the UNC Men's Basketball Program This Offseason (2025)
Several transfers have announced their intentions to join head coach Hubert Davis and UNC next season. Here’s a list of those incoming players: Luka Bogavac – SC Derby (ABA League) The first international commitment of the Hubert Davis-Jim Tanner era, Luka Bogavac was one of the top college-eligible players in Europe that college teams had […]
With 'Native Nations,' UNC's Kathleen DuVal Shifts Narratives, Wins Pulitzer
UNC historian Kathleen DuVal has won the Pulitzer Prize for her book "Native Nations: A Millennium in North America."
Knapp Dominant In Diamond Heels Shutout Win Over Holy Cross
UNC got 8 1/3 innings of shut-out, three-hit ball from ace Jake Knapp as they won their first NCAA tournament game of 2025 4-0 against Holy Cross.
'We Want Them To Feel Welcome': A Conversation with UNC Chancellor Lee Roberts, Part 2
UNC Chancellor Lee Roberts shares his thoughts on tenure delays, student visas, Bill Belichick, and the future of the Smith Center.
›