The University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill must release disciplinary records of students who violated the school’s sexual assault policies, the N.C. Supreme Court ruled Friday.
The 4-3 ruling reaffirmed a state Court of Appeals ruling in 2018, news outlets reported.
UNC-Chapel Hill was sued by a media coalition of Capitol Broadcasting Co., the Durham Herald Co., and the school’s student newspaper, The Daily Tar Heel. In September 2016, the group requested documents under the North Carolina Public Records Act connected with anyone found responsible for rape, sexual assault and other sexual misconduct by the UNC-Chapel Hill’s disciplinary bodies.
The university denied that request, setting off a legal battle that stretched over three years. University officials argued the records were protected by the Federal Education Rights and Privacy Act, which shields academic records from public disclosure.
The two sides argued over whether the state’s records law, which grants broad access to government documents, overrides FERPA — a federal statute designed to protect the privacy of students. Language in the federal law specifically calls out records related to violent and sexual crimes, saying universities may disclose three specific bits of information: the student’s name, the violation committed and any sanctions imposed on the students.
In May 2017, Orange County Superior Court Judge Allen Baddour ruled that FERPA preempts the public records law, which would mandate it in every case.
School officials have argued for years that they exercised the discretion granted by FERPA to protect victims and the confidentiality of the Title IX process. Writing for the majority, Associate Justice Michael Morgan concluded that UNC-Chapel Hill officials do not have that discretion in light of the state law requiring release of the records.
“Accordingly, as an agency of the state, UNC-CH must comply with the North Carolina Public Records Act and allow plaintiffs to have access to the name of the student, the violation committed, and any sanction imposed,” Morgan wrote.
Writing for the dissent, Associate Justice Mark Davis accused his colleagues of going “astray” with a “basic error that infects the majority’s entire analysis.”
“In doing so, the majority turns the preemption analysis on its head. It simply makes no sense to examine a provision of state law to determine whether Congress has conferred discretion upon universities,” Davis wrote.
The school expressed disappointment with the ruling.
“We respect the court’s deliberations and appreciate the opportunity to be heard during the appeals process. We are carefully reviewing the decision,” Joel Curran, UNC-Chapel Hill’s vice chancellor of communications, said in an email sent to WRAL.
Related Stories
‹
North Carolina Judge Challenging Outcome of Race Wore Confederate Uniform in College PhotoNorth Carolina judge and state Supreme Court candidate Jefferson Griffin posed in Confederate military garb while attending UNC in the 2000s.
Survey: A Third of UNC Female Undergraduate Students Have Been Sexually AssaultedUNC released a report Tuesday that showed one in three female undergraduate students at the school have experienced some form of sexual assault, according to a recent survey. The Association of American Universities conducted the survey in the spring of 2019 and found 35 percent of women undergraduates at UNC have experienced some form of unwanted […]
UNC Men's Basketball Beats USC Upstate, Improves to 9-1 This SeasonUNC closed the game on a 12-2 run to pull away from USC Upstate late and beat the Spartans 80-62 at the Smith Center Saturday afternoon. HEELS WIN.#CarolinaFamily | @WellsFargo pic.twitter.com/dc2Gix0J5W — Carolina Basketball (@UNC_Basketball) December 13, 2025 Carolina’s late run came after the Spartans had kept the game close for much of the afternoon. […]
College Football's Transfer Portal Opens January 2. Which Tar Heels Are Planning to Enter?The college football transfer portal will open Friday, January 2 and close at 11:59 p.m. on Friday, January 16. It will be the only transfer portal window of the year for college football, as the NCAA moved to eliminate the spring transfer window earlier this year. Players do not have to have committed to and […]
Chapel Hill Alerts Residents To Upcoming S. Columbia Road ClosureThe Town of Chapel Hill announced that a section of S. Columbia St. will be closed as UNC conducts maintenance on its steam tunnel system.
UNC Hospitals Recognized for Best Maternity CareUNC Hospitals in Chapel Hill was one of six UNC Health facilities across the state to be recognized in U.S. News & World Report’s 2026 list of Best Hospitals for Maternity Care. The list named all six UNC Health hospitals as “high performing,” which is the highest award a hospital can earn as part of […]
UNC Women's Basketball vs. Louisville (2025): How to Watch, Cord-Cutting Options and Tip-Off TimeCarolina will open ACC play when it hosts Louisville at Carmichael Arena Sunday afternoon. The Tar Heels have won three of the last four meetings with the Cardinals. If you aren’t attending the game in person, here’s how you can follow along at home: Broadcast Schedule Those hoping to listen on the radio can do […]
UNC Football: Belichick Fires Assistants Freddie Kitchens, Mike PrieferUNC football head coach Bill Belichick has begun shaking up his coaching staff, as he announced the firings of both offensive coordinator Freddie Kitchens and special teams coordinator Mike Priefer Friday morning. “We want to thank Coach Kitchens and Coach Priefer for their commitment and many contributions to our program and student-athletes,” Belichick said in […]
Chansky's Notebook: Year One DoneThe Bill Belichick Era at UNC is officially one year old. Right now, at least, infamy is the softest way to describe it.
![]()
Equity in Health Care - December 11, 2025What is the state of health care today, both nationally and here in our community? And what needs to be done to address disparities?
›
