Report: Charges Dismissed for 2 Accused of Helping Take Down Silent Sam

Two of the remaining people facing charges in the toppling of the Confederate statue known as Silent Sam saw their charges dismissed by the court system this week.

According to a report from The News & Observer on Wednesday, the charges for Raul Arce Jimenez and Shawn Birchfield-Finn were dropped due to the local court system working to prioritize certain cases amid limitations caused by COVID-19, Orange-Chatham District Attorney Jim Woodall told the newspaper. Jimenez and Birchfield-Finn were appealing their convictions on the charges as decided in 2019.

The Orange County Courthouse has been closed several times over the past year due to the pandemic due to state public health guidelines and localized outbreaks of the coronavirus — including most recently in October 2020.

“We’re not in control of COVID-19 and we’ve had no control over the fact that we’ve had court shut down, and realistically, it will be months and months before we ever get to these cases, and we simply have to prioritize,” Woodall told the News & Observer.

Jimenez and Birchfield-Finn were among more than a dozen people charged after the Confederate monument was pulled down in August 2018. The pair were charged with with injury to real property, misdemeanor riot and defacing a public statue or monument.

District Court Judge Lunsford Long convicted Jimenez and Birchfield-Finn of all three charges in 2019 and and sentenced them to 24 hours in jail. Scott Holmes, the attorney representing the pair, appealed the case to Superior Court and requested a jury trial, which delayed the sentence. Holmes said he received an email on Tuesday notifying him that the cases had been dismissed.

“I’m very pleased. I’m glad they did it,” Holmes told the News & Observer.

After Silent Sam was pulled down by protesters, it was placed in storage by UNC. In November 2019, a court approved a consent judgement that gave possession of the statue over to the Sons of Confederate Veterans. Under the terms, UNC was also tasked with funding a $2.5 million charitable trust for expenses related to the care and preservation of the monument.

Following criticism regarding the settlement and a revisit of the case, an Orange County judge returned possession of the statue was returned to UNC and voided the $2.5 million payment to the pro-Confederate group.

Chapelboro.com does not charge subscription fees. You can support local journalism and our mission to serve the community. Contribute today – every single dollar matters.

‹

Orange County Courthouse Closes Due to COVID-19 Exposure

The Orange County Courthouse will temporarily close to the public following “an exposure” to COVID-19. Court officials for the Hillsborough facility announced the closure on Tuesday, citing a recent threat to the public and court employees’ safety from the coronavirus. According to a release from the North Carolina Judicial Branch, those working at the courthouse […]

Ross Found Guilty Of Second-Degree Murder of Clark; Mistrial In Death Of Woods

Issiah Ross was found guilty of second degree murder of Devin Clark in 2022 but was not convicted for the shooting of Lyric Woods.

Issiah Ross Completes Testimony, Prosecution And Defense Deliver Closing Arguments In Woods/Clark Trial

Thursday saw the end of testimony and the closing arguments in the case against Issiah Ross in the shooting deaths of Lyric Woods and Devin Clark.

Issiah Ross Argues Self-Defense In Double Murder Trial; Prosecution Wraps Testimony

Issiah Ross took the stand Wednesday to share his own testimony and defense in the trial over the 2022 deaths of two teens in Orange County.

Ethics Probe Into North Carolina Justice’s Comments Continues After Federal Court Refuses to Halt It

Associate Justice Anita Earls sued the North Carolina Judicial Standards Commission in August and argued she used her First Amendment rights.

After Review, Orange County Says Boom in Hillsborough Was 2.2 Magnitude Earthquake

UPDATE: On Friday, the Orange County government said the U.S. Geological Survey completed a review and determined the loud noise ultimately was a small earthquake.

Nieman Sworn In as Orange, Chatham County's District Attorney

The 2022 election cycle brought about many changes among our community’s representation in the state and federal governments. But there was also a big change for Orange and Chatham County at district attorney.

Teenage Suspect in Orange County Double-Murder Makes First Superior Court Appearance

Issiah Ross, who is accused of killing two other teenagers in rural Orange County, made his first appearance in superior court.

Town of Hillsborough Unveils New Logo, Sticks With 'Iconic Clocktower' Symbol

The Town of Hillsborough unveiled its new logo on Wednesday — a reworking of the Historic Orange County Courthouse’s clock tower, which has been a symbol of Hillsborough for many years. The new logo, which was designed by Alison Duncan of Duncan Design in Pennsylvania, was selected by the Hillsborough Board of Commissioners last spring and […]

Report: Charges Dismissed for 2 Accused of Helping Take Down Silent Sam

Two of the remaining people facing charges in the toppling of the Confederate statue known as Silent Sam saw their charges dismissed by the court system this week. According to a report from The News & Observer on Wednesday, the charges for Raul Arce Jimenez and Shawn Birchfield-Finn were dropped due to the local court system working to […]

›