A heated county commissioner race in Chatham County saw Republican candidates fall short to two Democratic candidates and one unaffiliated newcomer on Tuesday night.

Current county commissioners Karen Howard and Mike Dasher won their respective races in District 01 and 02. Howard, who has served on the board since 2014, defeated former U.S. Army officer Jay Stobbs by just less than 4,000 votes. Dasher, who was elected in 2016, beat small business owner Jimmy Pharr by a similar margin, winning 54.4% of the vote.

Andy Wilkie, the lone Republican incumbent candidate who was appointed to the board in 2019, is down to unaffiliated candidate Franklin Gomez Flores at the end of Election Day. The Guatemalan-born and Siler City-based Flores led by a slim 322 votes with all of the county’s precincts reporting their voting totals. The race’s result may hinge on the final count of mailed-in absentee ballots, which will be accepted through November 12 as they arrive to the state Board of Elections.

If elected, Flores will become the first Latino commissioner in Chatham County’s history, which has seen its 12.5% Hispanic population continue to increase in recent years.

The commissioner races were tinged with tension left over the removal of a Confederate monument from the historic courthouse in Pittsboro, which the Board of County Commissioners voted to remove in August 2019. Protests as recent as Saturday saw community members come to blows over the issues of racism and support of the Confederacy.

Pharr, Stobbs and Wilkie campaigned together in Chatham County under the banner of more transparency from the board.

For more local, state and national election coverage, visit Chapelboro’s 2020 Elections page.

Chapelboro.com does not charge subscription fees. You can support local journalism and our mission to serve the community. Contribute today – every single dollar matters.

Related Stories
‹
'Can We Physically Have Him Removed?': Tension Spills Over at Chatham Commissioners Meeting
A recent meeting of Chatham County Commissioners grew heated, as outgoing commissioner David Delaney sparred with the rest of the board.
Robert Logan, Former School Superintendent, Appointed as Chatham County Commissioner
Chatham County Commissioners appointed Robert Logan on Monday to serve out the rest of Jim Crawford's unexpired term.
Chatham County Approves Two Referendums, Re-Elects County Commissioner
Chatham County voters turned out to the polls on Tuesday to re-elect incumbent county commissioner Mike Dasher to his seat on the board. But voters also passed two referendums on the ballot. Dasher defeated challenger candidate Katelin Hancock by earning 54 percent of the vote. He’s served on the Board of County Commissioners since 2016, including […]
Local Government Meetings: October 5-9, 2026
This week in local government: Orange County Commissioners discuss data centers and property revaluation, while Carrboro talks composting.
Local Government Meetings: September 28-October 2, 2026
This week in local government: Tongde Wu officially takes her oath of office as the newest member of the CHCCS school board.
The Morning News: Chatham vs. Data Centers, CHCCS Board Vacancy, UNC Player Eligibility
In today's news: the Chapel Hill-Carrboro school board will appoint a new member, and four UNC athletes have their eligibility restored.
Chatham County Commissioners Oppose Proposed Enbridge Gas Pipeline Through Resolution
The pipeline would run 28 miles through Chatham and Lee counties, and would pass through the private property of numerous residents.
Local Government Meetings: September 21-25, 2026
This week in local government: Chapel Hill weighs library card fees for out-of-towners, while the CHCCS board appoints a new member.
Local Government Meetings: September 14-18, 2026
This week in local government: a greenway network in Chapel Hill, and busing concerns and elementary school redistricting for CHCCS.
Photo Gallery: Chatham County Residents Voice Concerns With Enbridge Pipeline
Photographer Elena Pace captured photos of a special meeting regarding a proposed natural gas pipeline in Chatham County.
›