UNC has announced that two football players have suffered career ending medical problems, a neck injury and a heart condition.

I won’t mention their names, but I certainly am puzzled and troubled by why the university releases this type of personal health information.  Just think about whether you would want your health information the media.

Student health information is generally protected by the 1996 Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act commonly known as HIPAA and the 1974 Family Educational Rights and Privacy Act referred to as the Buckley Amendment.

Students who play sports, however, sign multiple waivers and release forms which may explain why this personal information is shared with the public.  A review of these forms is perplexing enough as to wonder whether the typical student knows what he or she is signing.

For example, as is the case with many consent forms, there is language to confirm that the student has signed voluntarily, that failure to sign will have no consequences on health care or participation in sports.

Given all the demands placed on athletes, one wonders if the option not to sign really reflects an autonomous choice.

Listen to more from The Commentators

As another example, language from one form to the next does not appear to be consistent.  Is the information released only in the aggregate for research on injuries or is it made available with individual identifiers like names and photos.

Athletics departments are quick to assert that athletes have given their consent.  But, what does that consent really mean?  And putting aside whether this behavior is legal or consistent with the rules and regulations of the NCAA, is it the right thing to do?

Why not respect the privacy of these students?

Finally, if it is somehow acceptable to share the most private of personal health information about athlete, why is it not equally acceptable to publish their transcripts to monitor educational progress with transparency?

— Lew Margolis

Related Stories
‹
Chansky's Notebook: Between the Lines
Bill Belichick's hiring at UNC has set off a social media spark that could be turning into a dumpster fire.
UNC Football 2025 Spring Transfer Portal Window Tracker: Arrivals
The spring window of the college football transfer portal opened Wednesday, April 16 and closed Friday, April 25. Players who intend to transfer must enter their names into the portal before the window closes, but do not need to have selected their next school by then. Here is a summary of which players have committed […]
'False Narrative': Read UNC Head Coach Bill Belichick's Statement on CBS Interview
Following the airing of an interview on the show ‘CBS Sunday Morning’ this past weekend, UNC football head coach Bill Belichick has issued a statement on what he calls “a false narrative” suggested through the piece. The interview with CBS’ Tony Dokoupil, which was mostly to promote Belichick’s new book, “The Art of Winning,” touches […]
Chansky's Notebook: Personal Privacy
Bill Belichick's private life is very public-facing right now, due in large part to his 24-year-old girlfriend Jordon Hudson.
Which Tar Heels are Going Where in the NFL? Check Out Our Full List.
Check out the full list of which UNC players are headed to the pros! NFL draftees, as well as undrafted free agents who sign contracts with pro teams, will be added to this list. RB Omarion Hampton – Los Angeles Chargers (R1, No. 22 overall) The Los Angeles Chargers made Hampton the first Tar Heel […]
Chansky's Notebook: Quiet Runner
UNC's Omarion Hampton is going to Los Angeles to play for the Chargers under run-oriented head coach Jim Harbaugh.
UNC RB Omarion Hampton Selected by Los Angeles Chargers in NFL Draft
One of the best running backs in UNC history is league-bound. Omarion Hampton was selected by the Los Angeles Chargers with the No. 22 overall pick in the first round of the 2025 NFL Draft Thursday night. He is the first Tar Heel selected in this year’s draft. let’s cook, O pic.twitter.com/rB5pcczCgb — Los Angeles […]
UNC Football 2025 Spring Transfer Portal Window Tracker: Departures
The spring window of the college football transfer portal opened Wednesday, April 16 and will close Friday, April 25. Players who intend to transfer must enter their names into the portal before the window closes, but do not need to have selected their next school by then. Here is a summary of which UNC players […]
'A Very Unique Opportunity': Read Bill Belichick's Comments on UNC Football's Trip to Ireland
The UNC football program formally announced its participation in the 2026 Aer Lingus College Football Classic in Dublin, Ireland Wednesday at the Kenan Football Center. Representing UNC at the event were chancellor Lee Roberts, athletic director Bubba Cunningham and head football coach Bill Belichick. They were joined by dignitaries from both the Republic of Ireland […]
UNC Football to Face TCU in Ireland in 2026 Season Opener
Carolina Football is going international. The Tar Heels will face TCU in the Aer Lingus College Football Classic in Dublin, Ireland to open the 2026 regular season. The game is scheduled for August 29, 2026 in Dublin’s Aviva Stadium. Pack your Passports! The Tar Heels are coming to the Emerald Isle in 2026! pic.twitter.com/ZPoEutfCaE — […]
›