UNC has announced that two football players have suffered career ending medical problems, a neck injury and a heart condition.
I won’t mention their names, but I certainly am puzzled and troubled by why the university releases this type of personal health information. Just think about whether you would want your health information the media.
Student health information is generally protected by the 1996 Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act commonly known as HIPAA and the 1974 Family Educational Rights and Privacy Act referred to as the Buckley Amendment.
Students who play sports, however, sign multiple waivers and release forms which may explain why this personal information is shared with the public. A review of these forms is perplexing enough as to wonder whether the typical student knows what he or she is signing.
For example, as is the case with many consent forms, there is language to confirm that the student has signed voluntarily, that failure to sign will have no consequences on health care or participation in sports.
Given all the demands placed on athletes, one wonders if the option not to sign really reflects an autonomous choice.
As another example, language from one form to the next does not appear to be consistent. Is the information released only in the aggregate for research on injuries or is it made available with individual identifiers like names and photos.
Athletics departments are quick to assert that athletes have given their consent. But, what does that consent really mean? And putting aside whether this behavior is legal or consistent with the rules and regulations of the NCAA, is it the right thing to do?
Why not respect the privacy of these students?
Finally, if it is somehow acceptable to share the most private of personal health information about athlete, why is it not equally acceptable to publish their transcripts to monitor educational progress with transparency?
— Lew Margolis
Related Stories
‹
UNC Football's Upcoming Home-and-Home Series With South Carolina CancelledThe UNC football program’s upcoming home-and-home series against South Carolina has been cancelled. The Tar Heels were scheduled to visit Columbia in 2028 and host the Gamecocks in Chapel Hill in 2029. In a brief release, UNC said the expanded conference schedules in both the SEC and ACC, which will see schools play nine league […]
UNC Teases Kenan Stadium Enhancements as Venue Prepares to Celebrate 100 YearsThe 2026 UNC football season will be the 100th in which the Tar Heels have called Kenan Stadium home, and the program is prepared to celebrate the historic venue with several upgrades and enhancements this fall. Two new video boards will be installed above each end zone, with both measuring 31.5 feet high by 106.5 […]
Chansky's Notebook: Draft Dodgers?Bill Belichick and Michael Malone have found themselves in the same undesirable dilemma: neither has any draft picks.
'I Can Do This For a Long Time': Bobby Petrino Excited for New Challenge With UNC FootballLet’s get one thing out of the way first: UNC’s new offensive coordinator is known for more than just being a football coach. Ask Atlanta Falcons fans about Bobby Petrino’s antics. Or the folks in Louisville. Or Arkansas. The paper trail that follows Petrino everywhere he goes is long, and it bends toward absurdity. Egregiously […]
Chansky's Notebook: Dead Man Walking?With Hubert Davis dismissed, no seat will be hotter in Chapel Hill than UNC head football coach Bill Belichick’s this fall.
Chansky's Notebook: 'We Have Our Team Now'Bill Belichick spoke to the media at the Kenan Football Center Tuesday as UNC opened its spring practice season.
Chansky's Notebook: Mack is Back (Again)Mack Brown's midcourt ceremony at the Smith Center Monday night was a satisfying end to what had been an awkward UNC football saga.
Here's a List of Which Transfers Have Committed to UNC Football in 2026The college football transfer portal opened Friday, Jan. 2 and closed Friday, Jan. 16. Here’s a list of players who have committed to head coach Bill Belichick and UNC out of the portal so far, with their classes for the 2026 season: QB Billy Edwards, Jr. (Most recent school: Wisconsin, redshirt senior) Ranked 3rd in […]
Tributes Pour In After James Spurling, Director of Kenan Stadium, Dies at 68James Spurling, who served as the Director of Kenan Stadium and the Kenan Football Center in the heart of the UNC campus since 2006 and had been a Chapel Hill staple for many years prior, died Thursday. He was 68 years old. Tributes flooded in from across the Chapel Hill and UNC sports communities following […]
Financial Report Shows UNC Athletics Operated at $15 Million Deficit in 2024-25 YearThe newest financial report from the UNC athletic department to the NCAA shows the department operated at a deficit of more than $15 million during the 2024-25 fiscal year. The department reported revenues of $172,951,034 and reported expenses of $187,967,260. The UNC athletic department had operated at a profit in each of the past three […]
›
