How is the NCAA going to enforce new NIL guidelines?

To use a term from modern communications, who is Zooming who here? The NCAA, which washed its hands of regulating and watch-dogging the Name-Image-Likeness deals on each campus, is now taking charge again. I don’t think so.

The NCAA will be knee-capped by all the lawsuits coming its way, whether being sued for any number of things or serving as a material witness for all the different ways NIL money is now paid outside of its original guidelines.

Mack Brown has made it clear from the middle of last season, the confluence of the transfer portal and NIL money is destroying the one condition everyone was supposed to understand and abide by from the beginning.

College athletes can’t be paid to play or be paid per touchdown or 3-pointer. Yet, when players transfer to another school that has, one way or another, offered or implied NIL is money waiting for them, the entire system has broken down.

And it cannot change if wealthy alumni and corporate CEOs are answering with court injunctions, restraint of trade claims and enough money and moxie to create the gigantic legal mess the NCAA has been trying to avoid for years.

Collectives are rich alumni and companies joining together to create a war chest to buy the best players from high school or the transfer portal. And the athletes will be on their side if their predecessors made a bunch and the NCAA is blocking theirs.

The most egregious part of it is that some schools crossed the guidelines from the get-go. Coaches and administrators are explicitly not supposed to be involved in any way. Athletes can hire agents or make deals themselves with local businesses.

Right off the bat, BYU partnered with a protein bar company that paid every walk-on football player’s tuition, and the school associate athletic director openly told the media about his brokering the deal. Does it matter that they’re only walk-ons?

BYU is now small potatoes, with collectives paying millions into talent agencies like CAA in New York that funnel promised payments to star athletes at their schools. That sounds unfixable.

Chapelboro.com does not charge subscription fees, and you can directly support our efforts in local journalism here. Want more of what you see on Chapelboro? Let us bring free local news and community information to you by signing up for our biweekly newsletter.

Podcast: Play in new window | Download

Subscribe: RSS

Related Stories
‹
Chansky's Notebook: The 'We'll See' Era
How much NIL money athletes may be paid by schools will not be sorted out for at least a year and will only complicate matters more.
Chansky's Notebook: NIL Nightmare?
No matter what Ian Jackson is paid by adidas, he cannot wear their shoes or any of their apparel when he is on the court at UNC.
Chansky's Notebook: Getting 'Aligned'
As of yesterday, Mack Brown's pleading appears to be working on the Heels4Life NIL tally, if not in the court of social media.
Chansky's Notebook: Call to Arms
Since UNC lost more players than it has signed in the transfer portal, Mack Brown is ready to take the next step.
Chansky's Notebook: NIL Week
The NIL demands on a player like an All-American quarterback have to be immense, even if he only can meet a fraction of multiple requests.
Chansky's Notebook: Old Way Working
Art Chansky’s Sports Notebook is presented by The Casual Pint. YOUR place for delicious pub food paired with local beer. Choose among 35 rotating taps and 200+ beers in the cooler. Carolina continues to sell the 40-year commitment more than NIL. The football Tar Heels have 24 commitments in the high school class of 2024 […]
Chansky's Notebook: Depth and Experience
If NIL is the great separator, the transfer portal is the great equalizer. College athletics has been very confusing the last few years, thanks to the implementation of Name-Image-Likeness allowing certain amateur athletes to be paid like pros. That only applies to a small percentage of elite jocks who make the big bucks from their […]
Chansky's Notebook: The 'Worthy Burger' Days
Do we owe Worthy, Ford and Cunningham any old NIL money? Armando Bacot is in the news a lot lately, and in the off-season so little of it is for playing basketball. The Tar Heels’ rising senior center-forward decided to stay in school and get his degree, and he also beat the mock draft boards, […]
Glenn's Notebook: A New Reality
Three members of the NCAA enforcement staff visited the University of Miami last week, in what is believed to be the organization’s first inquiry into whether some of the name-image-likeness agreements between college athletes and various third parties are being done in violation of NCAA rules. For several reasons, the Miami case is a good […]
Chansky's Notebook: Fight For the Almighty Dollar
Can lavish facilities trump the glut of NIL money? Carolina is in the closing stages of another multimillion-dollar expansion to its football center. From advance reports, the Tar Heels will have a Disneyland type of training and conditioning addition to the Kenan Football Center that was completed just as Mack Brown left UNC for Texas […]
›