Written by THE ASSOCIATED PRESS

Students at the University of North Carolina can continue their lawsuit seeking monetary damages for fees they paid before in-person fall 2020 classes were canceled due to COVID-19, a state appeals court ruled.

A three-judge panel of the Court of Appeals decided on Tuesday that a trial judge correctly last year refused to dismiss litigation filed by two students against the UNC Board of Governors. The students — Landry Kuehn at UNC-Chapel Hill and the Joseph Lannan at North Carolina State University — also sued on behalf of other students at the two schools who paid similar fees.

The lawsuit alleged a breach of contract occurred when the students who registered for the fall 2020 semester paid health service, campus security and parking fees among others with an understanding that services and benefits would be provided, but they weren’t. The students alleged they failed to receive proper refunds when campuses like N.C. State and UNC-Chapel Hill moved in-person classes online, “evicted all students from on-campus housing” and curtailed health services.

Lannan is due about $1,500 and Kuehn about $1,125, the lawsuit alleges, while other students at their schools at that time should be recompensed, too. The board’s lawyers have written previously that students had been informed that the instruction format during the semester could change and that fee refunds would not be forthcoming if that occurred.

The Board of Governors argued on the appeal in part that the lawsuit should be dismissed on grounds of sovereign immunity, which blocks such litigation against state government unless an agency consents.

Writing for the panel, Court of Appeals Chief Judge Chris Donna Stroud said the plaintiffs adequately alleged the existence of an implied contract, which can waive such immunity. Judges Chris Dillon and Darren Jackson joined in Stroud’s opinion. The UNC board could ask the state Supreme Court to take up the case, but the justices aren’t obligated to do so given that the opinion was unanimous.

North Carolina campuses similarly eliminated online classes and closed dormitories during the spring 2020 semester, but the General Assembly passed a law that year giving public and private colleges immunity from pandemic-related legal claims for tuition and fees. But it didn’t apply to claims in future semesters.

 

 

Related Stories
‹
UNC System Chooses Kenan-Flagler Alum, Former Domino's CEO as Latest UNC-Chapel Hill Trustee
Ritch Allison — who was formally selected Thursday by the UNC System — will fill the Board of Trustees seat left vacant by Dave Boliek.
Here's What UNC President Peter Hans Said About Picking Lee Roberts to Lead UNC-Chapel Hill
The UNC Board of Governors approved Lee Roberts to take off the ‘interim’ tag to his role as chancellor of UNC-Chapel Hill on Friday. The vote by the board came after UNC System President Peter Hans nominated Roberts and gave an extended speech on the selection process, Roberts’ approach to leadership, and his own vision […]
Board of Governors Set Friday Meeting to Elect New UNC Chancellor
The search for the next permanent UNC chancellor is coming to a close, as the UNC Board of Governors will hold a special meeting on Friday.
'Ready to Roll Up My Sleeves': UNC Interim Chancellor Shares Early Impressions On the Job
UNC Interim Chancellor Lee Roberts spoke with the media on Thursday for the first time since being named to the role in December.
UNC Housekeepers Rally in Chapel Hill, Raleigh for Pay Raises
Several housekeepers, students and community members gathered for rallies on Wednesday to call for action from the UNC Board of Governors.
Court OKs Dismissing UNC Student Suit Seeking Virus Refunds
Written by THE ASSOCIATED PRESS A trial judge was correct to dismiss a lawsuit filed by then-University of North Carolina students seeking tuition, housing and fee refunds when in-person instruction was canceled during the 2020 spring semester as the coronavirus pandemic began, the state Court of Appeals ruled Tuesday. Several students at UNC system campuses and […]
One on One: Can’t Stop UNC’s Move to Raleigh
Editor’s Note: The UNC System has shared with Chapelboro.com that UNC President Peter Hans does live in the university president’s home. The column does not yet reflect that fact. Too late. It has already been done. The Spangler building that served as headquarters of the UNC System is dark and empty for the first time […]
National Group ‘Resoundingly Condemns’ UNC System
The American Association of University Professors (AAUP) governing council voted unanimously to condemn the UNC System on Thursday.
UNC System Board of Governors Approves 4 New Trustees for UNC-CH
The UNC System Board of Governors approved several new trustees for UNC-Chapel Hill during its monthly full board meeting. The university system leadership approved Rob Bryan III, Perrin Jones, Malcom Turner and Ramsey White on Thursday morning, adding them to the ranks of the Chapel Hill university’s Board of Trustees. Bryan, Jones and White’s appointments […]
State Budget Impasse Looms Large Over UNC System Board Meeting
The continued budget standoff in the North Carolina legislature loomed large at the UNC System’s first Board of Governors meeting of 2020. The state government’s day-long session earlier in the week, which led to no resolution between Democratic lawmakers and Republican lawmakers over the proposed budget, dominated the comments of system leadership on Friday from […]
›