A student-athlete advocacy group is pursuing a civil-rights complaint against the University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill and claiming discrimination against male athletes and particularly black male athletes who were placed in courses requiring only a research paper.
The Student-Athletes Human Rights Project filed the complaint Friday to the U.S. Department of Education’s Office for Civil Rights. It alleges gender and race discrimination because the classes didn’t provide a quality education.
The “paper classes” in the formerly named African and Afro-American Studies department were often billed as lecture courses but were treated as independent studies with no classroom time and significant athlete enrollments. Those classes were among findings of fraud in the department dating to the late 1990s.
That led to several university reviews, including an investigation currently being conducted by U.S. Justice Department veteran Kenneth Wainstein.
According to a copy of the complaint, black student-athletes were “disproportionately enrolled” in the courses compared to white student-athletes. Male student-athletes also made up more enrollments than female athletes, a sign they “are not provided with the same educational opportunities,” according to the complaint.
The complaint cites research by UNC reading specialist Mary Willingham on academically at-risk school athletes from 2004-12. Willingham has said the classes helped keep athletes eligible despite many reading at below-grade levels.
The school has disputed Willingham’s findings on athlete literacy levels and hired outside consultants to review her research. Willingham has stood firm that her findings are correct.
Related Stories
‹

Chansky's Notebook: 'In My Mind...'UNC is tackling a problem in its football day-game atmosphere in another way this season, with the "Chapel Thrill" Game Day Experience.

UNC Women's Soccer Trounces Siena in 2025 Home OpenerUNC bounced back from its opening-night loss at Tennessee by throttling visiting Siena in the home opener at Dorrance Field Sunday afternoon. The Tar Heels scored four second-half goals on their way to a 5-0 win. First 𝙒 of the season🤩#GoHeels x @WellsFargo pic.twitter.com/EUy8ofu349 — UNC Women's Soccer (@uncwomenssoccer) August 17, 2025 Bella Gaetino opened […]
![]()
On Air Today: UNC Volleyball Head Coach Mike Schall on the Upcoming 2025 SeasonUNC Volleyball Head Coach Mike Schall joins 97.9 The Hill News Director Brighton McConnell in-studio on Thursday, August 15.

Bubba Cunningham Details Revenue Allocations Among UNC Sports Programs for 2025-26 YearUNC athletic director Bubba Cunningham broke down how the school will be sharing athletic revenue with its sports programs in an interview with the Carolina Insider Podcast Friday morning. Cunningham said the money, which totals more than $20.5 million (roughly 22 percent of revenue for the four major college conferences, as determined by the House […]

Chansky's Notebook: Building DNAThe Bill Belichick way, from New England to UNC, has always been that preparation has been more important than the games.

Upsets, Close Calls and More: Looking Back on Notable Opening Games for UNC FootballThere are less than three weeks to go until UNC opens its 2025 season against TCU in Kenan Stadium. The game has been sold out for weeks, and ESPN will broadcast it live to a national audience. Dignitaries such as former Alabama head coach Nick Saban will be on-hand for a special pregame show live […]

No. 1 UNC Women's Soccer Drops Season Opener at TennesseeTop-ranked Carolina’s title defense got off to a bumpy start. The Tar Heels gave up a pair of second-half goals on their way to a 2-0 defeat in the regular-season opener against Tennessee in Knoxville Thursday night. It’s the first time since 2014 UNC has lost the first match of the season. Though Carolina doubled […]

UNC Men's Basketball Finalizes Roster, Jersey Numbers for 2025-26 SeasonHead coach Hubert Davis and the UNC men’s basketball program have finalized the team’s roster and jersey numbers ahead of the 2025-26 season. The Tar Heels bring in numerous newcomers between freshmen and transfers after losing all five of their year-end starters from the 2024-25 season. The squad is set ‼️ 🔗 https://t.co/58XUN10ZNl pic.twitter.com/GvWO19lPgH — […]

Chansky's Notebook: Let's Go, Ladies!The UNC field hockey and women's soccer programs are set to be nationally competitive once again this fall.

'I Love the Challenge': UNC Football's Mike Priefer Sees Opportunity in Special Teams OverhaulNew UNC special teams coordinator Mike Priefer feels he has the pieces in place to improve what has been a mediocre unit.
›