North Carolina’s highest court began weighing a claim Monday by six inmates on death row who say they are there because of racial discrimination in jury selection — and who argue they are still entitled to protections under a law that was taken off the books.

The state Supreme Court began hearing arguments in the cases of four inmates who briefly were resentenced to life without parole when legislators approved the Racial Justice Act in 2009. Legislators repealed the law in 2013. Justices also heard from attorneys for two other death row prisoners whose Racial Justice Act claims weren’t decided before the law’s repeal.

“Weighing on this court’s shoulders is hundreds of years of racial discrimination against African Americans,” attorney Henderson Hill told the justices.

The Supreme Court — which has seven justices, six of whom are Democrats — typically doesn’t determine facts, but Hill suggested that perhaps it should. Prosecutors get so many opportunities to strike potential jurors from duty that “simple math means that black folks are going to be disenfranchised from service on juries,” he said. “With all that history, how does the court respond?”

As Hill was concluding his arguments focused on racial discrimination in jury selection in North Carolina, Chief Justice Cheri Beasley said: “It sounds like while we are here in the context of these cases, it sounds like … you’re addressing something greater and possibly asking this court to address something greater.”

Another defense attorney, Dan Shatz, argued that the justices should consider the 1866 Amnesty Act that provided blanket protection to Confederate soldiers accused of crimes. The court found that even after the law was repealed, it still provided amnesty to an officer who led a civilian massacre.

Under the RJA, condemned men and women could seek a life sentence without parole by using statistics to show that race tainted their trials. Of the 142 people on North Carolina’s death row, 36% are white.

The four cases where the prisoners were briefly resentenced all come from Cumberland County, including Hill’s client, Christina Walters, a Native American who is one of three women on North Carolina’s death row. The justices were scheduled to hear five of the cases Monday with one scheduled for Tuesday.

Senior Deputy Attorney General Danielle Elder argued that justices’ decision is limited and narrow — whether a lower court judge was correct to rule that the RJA, once appealed, no longer applied to Walters who was then returned to death row.

“What is properly before this court is a review of that court’s legal conclusion,” Elder said.

Elder also argued that the defendants still retain the right to a trial free of prejudicial error that could cause harm to the defendant. The repeal of the RJA did not affect the commitment of the nation “to the eradication of racial discrimination, which is odious in all respects, but especially in the administration of justice,” she said.

Related Stories
‹
Cooper, Three Former NC Governors File Brief Supporting UNC Admission Practices
As the U.S. Supreme Court examines race-conscious admission practices at UNC, four North Carolina governors submitted a brief in support of the university and its practices. Current Governor Roy Cooper, as well as former Governors Mike Easley, Bev Purdue and Jim Hunt filed the amicus brief for an ongoing lawsuit against UNC that will see […]
2020 Serves Another Blow as Ginsburg’s Death Ignites Fight
Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg’s death drew mourners to the steps of the Supreme Court, where they sang “Amazing Grace” in the dark. Fresh off a rally stage in Minnesota, President Donald Trump learned of the loss and praised Ginsburg as an “amazing” woman. Such grace notes didn’t last long. They were overwhelmed as swiftly as […]
NC Death Row Inmate to Serve Life in Prison, Court Rules
A man on death row in North Carolina will soon have his sentence reduced to life without parole, the state Supreme Court ruled on Friday. Marcus Robinson is one of four inmates to initially get death penalty sentences reduced using the legal process outlined in the now-defunct Racial Justice Act. The 2009 law allowed death […]
Supreme Court Narrows Lifetime GPS Tracking of Sex Offenders
Some repeat convicted sex offenders in North Carolina who’ve completed their sentences should no longer be subject to perpetual monitoring by satellite-linked bracelets because it’s unconstitutional, the state Supreme Court ruled Friday. A majority on the state’s highest court expanded a lower appeals court decision that last year concluded GPS monitoring of Torrey Grady — […]
North Carolina GOP Rep. Grange Enters 2020 Governor's Race
A North Carolina state legislator entered the 2020 Republican gubernatorial race Thursday, a decision that denies Lt. Gov. Dan Forest a cleared path to the GOP nomination after preparing for years for a bid. State Rep. Holly Grange of Wilmington announced her candidacy in a campaign video that highlighted her as one of the first female West […]
N Carolina Justice says Democratic Colleagues are 'AOCs'
The North Carolina Supreme Court’s only registered Republican called out the remaining six Democratic justices in a speech that marked an unusual open critique of the state’s highest court from within. In a campaign address last weekend to Republicans, Associate Justice Paul Newby compared his Democratic colleagues to New York Rep. Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez. To GOP […]
Supreme Court Won't Block Districts Drawn for Partisan Gain
The Supreme Court says federal courts have no role to play in policing political districts drawn for partisan gain. The decision could embolden political line-drawing for partisan gain when state lawmakers undertake the next round of redistricting following the 2020 census. The justices said by a 5-4 vote on Thursday that claims of partisan gerrymandering […]
Cooper Elevates Court of Appeals Judge to Supreme Court
North Carolina Gov. Roy Cooper added a sixth Democrat to the seven-member state Supreme Court on Monday, elevating a current Court of Appeals judge to a vacancy created when Cooper recently named Cheri Beasley the chief justice. Cooper, also a Democrat, announced he’s appointing Judge Mark Davis as an associate justice. Davis will begin serving […]
Public Support for Death Penalty Waning in North Carolina
A new poll from Public Policy Polling has found that a majority of North Carolinians believe the death penalty should be replaced with alternative punishments. Voters question the fairness of the death penalty on several fronts, including racial bias, judicial error and mental health of the accused at the time of the crime. Director of […]
Group Takes on Death Penalty in N Carolina Court Brief
A former Superior Court judge is among those asking the North Carolina Supreme Court to find the death penalty unconstitutional because its rare use means it serves no purpose. In a friend-of-the-court brief , the group also argues that the death penalty is “cruel or unusual” under the state constitution. The Promise of Justice Initiative filed the […]
›