Long-Running North Carolina Education Case Will Return Before the State Supreme Court in February

Written by THE ASSOCIATED PRESS

More arguments in education funding litigation that goes back nearly 30 years are scheduled for early next year at the North Carolina Supreme Court.

The state’s highest court is revisiting the case originally known as “Leandro” with oral arguments it has now set for Feb. 22.

That will be less than 16 months after a majority of justices — then all of the court’s registered Democrats — ruled a trial judge could order taxpayer dollars be transferred without the General Assembly’s express approval from government coffers to state agencies to carry out a plan to address longstanding education inequities.

Since the 4-3 opinion in November 2022, the court has flipped to a 5-2 GOP majority.

Republican justices agreed in October to hear an appeal by Republican legislative leaders as to whether Judge James Ammons had the authority last spring to enter an order declaring that the state owed $678 million to fulfill two years of the eight-year plan. The justices are expected to examine whether the judge could rule about public education statewide.

Republican legislative leaders are opposed to the November 2022 ruling and argue state funds can only be allocated with General Assembly approval.

They also said in court filings this year that there was never a legal determination made that school districts statewide had failed to live up to the requirement affirmed by the Supreme Court in rulings in 1997 and 2004 that the state constitution directs all children must receive the “opportunity to receive a sound basic education.”

Associate Justice Anita Earls, a Democrat, wrote in October that the matter should not be revisited. She said an earlier trial judge managing the case did find a statewide constitutional violation of education inequities, and so a statewide remedy was needed.

Lawyers representing several school districts in poor counties also argued in court filings that the case was settled in November 2022 and should not be reheard.

The case began in 1994, when several school districts and families of children — one whose last name was Leandro — sued the state over alleged state law and constitutional violations involving education.

Photo via the Chatham News + Record.

‹

Robert's Rules: Leandro Limbo, Roles of the Legislature and Private School Drawbacks

North Carolina House Minority Leader and Chatham County Representative Robert Reives speaks with 97.9 The Hill on Wednesday, February 28.

N. Carolina Governor Talks Prosperity, Culture War Warning

Written by GARY D. ROBERTSON and HANNAH SCHOENBAUM North Carolina Democratic Gov. Roy Cooper urged legislators on Monday night to keep fueling opportunities for the state’s citizens to succeed through more monetary investments in K-12 education, mental health services and public safety. “Our moment to build enduring prosperity is now. And I know that North […]

New Judge Taking Over North Carolina School Funding Case

Written by THE ASSOCIATED PRESS A new trial judge is presiding over a long-running North Carolina school funding case — in particular compliance with a recent state Supreme Court ruling that declared the judicial branch correctly ordered funds be spent to address education inequities. Chief Justice Paul Newby assigned Superior Court Judge James Ammons last week to […]

N. Carolina Justices Weigh Who Has School Spending Authority

Written by GARY D. ROBERTSON North Carolina’s highest court returned Wednesday to an education funding case originating almost 30 years ago, hearing arguments over whether a judge had unilateral power to allocate hundreds of millions in taxpayer dollars to address unresolved student inequities. Attorneys for students, their parents and state government’s executive branch contend it […]

NC’s Highest Court Again Weighs in on School Funding Case

Written by THE ASSOCIATED PRESS North Carolina’s highest court is considering whether it was within a trial judge’s power to unilaterally order taxpayer money be sent to government agencies to address stubborn educational inequities. The state Supreme Court scheduled oral arguments on Wednesday in another chapter of a decades-long legal struggle over public education spending and a […]

Lawyers Want NC Justice to Stay Out of School Funding Case

Written by THE ASSOCIATED PRESS A North Carolina Supreme Court justice should stay out of ruling in a longstanding public education funding case because many years ago she represented some of the plaintiffs in the litigation and filed briefs in the matter, Republican legislative leaders said Wednesday. Lawyers for House Speaker Tim Moore and Senate […]

North Carolina Senate OKs $500 Million for Private School Vouchers, Student Accounts

Written by GARY D. ROBERTSON North Carolina Senate Republicans pushed legislation through their chamber Thursday to set aside roughly $500 million more for now for programs that provide taxpayer money to help K-12 students attend private schools and eliminate their waiting lists. On a party-line 28-15 vote, the majority-Republican Senate agreed to spend the money. […]

Engrossed in Education Funding Dispute, North Carolina Revisits Milestone 2022 Ruling

North Carolina's Supreme Court returned Thursday to its landmark 2022 ruling in the Leandro Case. Republican lawmakers want it pulled back.

At His Old School, Term-Limited North Carolina Governor Takes New Tack on Public Education Funding

Cooper said on Tuesday he'd seek to build a coalition to prod the General Assembly to improve public schools toward his policy preferences.

Long-Running North Carolina Education Case Will Return Before the State Supreme Court in February

Written by THE ASSOCIATED PRESS More arguments in education funding litigation that goes back nearly 30 years are scheduled for early next year at the North Carolina Supreme Court. The state’s highest court is revisiting the case originally known as “Leandro” with oral arguments it has now set for Feb. 22. That will be less […]

›