School Funding Plaintiffs Ask NC Supreme Court To Weigh In

Written by THE ASSOCIATED PRESS

Plaintiffs in long-running North Carolina school funding litigation have asked the state’s highest court to decide whether a trial judge’s directive to send $1.75 billion from government coffers to state agencies to address inequities is lawful.

Lawyers representing school districts and parents on behalf of their children filed two separate appeal notices dated Wednesday with the state Supreme Court.

They are unhappy with last month’s decision by a Court of Appeals panel that blocked Superior Court Judge David Lee’s order to send the money from being enforced, and want the justices to get involved.

Lee is overseeing the litigation known as “Leandro,” named for one of the plaintiffs in the original lawsuit filed in 1994.

The judge declared last month that he had authority to direct funds from the state treasury because elected officials had failed repeatedly to comply with previous Supreme Court rulings that declared the state constitution gives children the “opportunity to receive a sound basic education.”

The $1.75 billion would cover two years of a remedial spending plan. It was developed by an outside consultant with input from Gov. Roy Cooper’s office and the State Board of Education.

Republicans leading the General Assembly said Lee had no such power, since appropriating state funds rests solely with the legislature. A majority on a Court of Appeals panel, responding to a request for intervention by State Controller Linda Combs, agreed Nov. 30 that Lee overstepped his bounds and blocked the transfer.

The plaintiffs’ lawyers question whether the appeal panel’s quick ruling ran counter to rules of appellate procedure, as well as to the state constitution and Supreme Court opinions. Lee wrote last month that a portion of the constitution addressing the right to education in part gave him the authority to appropriate funds for education without a specific law of the General Assembly.

“The children of North Carolina have waited long enough for vindication of their constitutional right to the opportunity for a sound basic education and deserve no less,” wrote Melanie Dubis, one of the plaintiffs’ lawyers, to the Supreme Court.

Last week, House Speaker Tim Moore and Senate leader Phil Berger asked Lee that they be allowed to formally intervene as defendants in the Leandro case. Lee’s order effective challenges the state budget that the General Assembly approves, as well as the legislature’s constitutional authority, the GOP leaders’ attorneys wrote.

Cooper, a Democrat, sought unsuccessfully for the remedial plan to be funded in the recently passed budget law.

Photo via the North Carolina Judicial Branch.

‹

Judge: N Carolina Must Spend $1.75B to Narrow Education Gap

Written by GARY D. ROBERTSON A North Carolina trial judge on Wednesday ordered the state to pay out $1.75 billion to help narrow the state’s public education inequities, angering Republicans who said the directive usurps lawmakers’ constitutional authority over state coffers. Superior Court Judge David Lee, who is charged with overseeing corrective responses to school […]

NC Public Education 'Remedial Plan' Presented to Judge

A multibillion-dollar plan presented by North Carolina officials and designed to comply with legal rulings that declare the state has failed to meet constitutional obligations in public education is now in the hands of a judge. The State Board of Education and Democratic Gov. Roy Cooper’s administration filed this week in Wake County court a […]

NC Judge: No Explanation for Replacement in ‘Leandro’ Case

Written by GARY D. ROBERTSON A retired judge who has managed longstanding litigation on K-12 education spending in North Carolina for years said he’s received no direct explanation why he’s not handling the next portion of the case. Superior Court Judge David Lee has been overseeing the lawsuit called “Leandro” since late 2016. But this […]

‘Leandro’ Fast-tracked to Justices; New Judge Directs Review

Written by GARY D. ROBERTSON North Carolina’s justices have agreed to accelerate the process that will likely lead to another landmark ruling over inequities in the public schools and the state’s role in removing them — such as whether courts can order that taxpayer money be spent. The state Supreme Court granted a request backed […]

Judge: No Waiting on NC Budget To Act on School Funding

Written by GARY D. ROBERTSON A North Carolina judge signaled Monday that he’s ready to formally demand legislators carry out a funding recipe to reduce public education inequities, saying he wouldn’t wait on a negotiated budget agreement between the governor and legislature before acting. Superior Court Judge David Lee told lawyers representing local school boards […]

Cooper: I’ll Seek Public School Spending Surge in NC Budget

Written by GARY D. ROBERTSON Soon entering the critical phase of North Carolina’s budget talks, Democratic Gov. Roy Cooper said Tuesday he would aim to get Republican lawmakers to fund public education improvements a judge says the state must start implementing. Addressing a panel he created to help comply with legal rulings in a decades-old […]

North Carolina GOP Again Seeking To Limit Racial Teachings

Written by HANNAH SCHOENBAUM A previously vetoed proposal advancing in the North Carolina House would restrict how teachers can discuss certain racial topics in the classroom amid a national GOP crusade against ideas they associate with “ critical race theory.” The bill, which passed Tuesday in the House Education Committee, would ban public schools from compelling students […]

Health Experts, Orange County Officials Share Concern for LGBTQ Wellbeing in Wake of NC Bills

The passage of two bills by the North Carolina General Assembly has drawn condemnation from some elected bodies in Orange County and local pediatric health experts alike for their anti-LGBTQ+ elements. The bills’ sponsors say the elimination of gender-affirming medical care for those under 18, as well as the requirement of educators to alert parents […]

North Carolina Senate Again Seeking LGBTQ Limits in Schools

Written by HANNAH SCHOENBAUM A bill advancing in North Carolina’s Senate would prohibit instruction about sexuality and gender identity in K-4 public school classes, defying the recommendations of parents, educators and LGBTQ youths who testified against it. Sponsors of the bill, approved Wednesday by the Senate education committee, say they want to grant parents greater authority […]

School Funding Plaintiffs Ask NC Supreme Court To Weigh In

Written by THE ASSOCIATED PRESS Plaintiffs in long-running North Carolina school funding litigation have asked the state’s highest court to decide whether a trial judge’s directive to send $1.75 billion from government coffers to state agencies to address inequities is lawful. Lawyers representing school districts and parents on behalf of their children filed two separate […]

›