A large crowd is expected to attend the Orange County Schools Board of Education meeting Monday night – the first board meeting since a surprise shakeup in board leadership earlier this month.

With no discussion in open session at the meeting on May 6, the board voted to appoint Will Atherton as board chair and Tony McKnight as vice chair, replacing Brenda Stephens and Sarah Smylie respectively. Smylie had announced her intention to step down as board vice chair, triggering a series of 4-3 votes resulting in the new chair and vice chair.

During the voting process, members of the public voiced concern over the board’s actions and the lack of public discourse.

“We’re supposed to get an opportunity to speak,” one said.

Another member of the public continued to speak as the board was voting via write-in ballot on who would be chosen to lead the board.

“This is not ok, at all,” she said. “I’ve never witnessed anything like this.”

Concern from the community ranged beyond the public nature of Monday’s decision, to also point out that the four male members of the board were voting – against the votes of the three women on the board – to remove the black, female board chair. Stephens appeared to attempt to reassure the public.

“They can take the chair, but they cannot take the voice,” Stephens said.

The Hate-Free School Coalition in the county, an advocacy group pushing for reforms in the school district, is working to mobilize community members to attend Monday night’s meeting and oppose the recent board restructuring.

Atheron has indicated to the News & Observer and the News of Orange that the decision to restructure the board was related to decisions made during a recent investigation of an incident in the school district. Atherton has not returned requests for comment to WCHL.

The board will have to hold another leadership vote in July.

Monday night’s meeting is scheduled to begin at 7 p.m. at Gravelly Hill Middle School.

Related Stories
‹
The Morning News: Anti-AI Protest, Racial Incident at UNC, K-12 School Grades
In today's news: this week's G20 Innovation Ministerial at the Carolina Inn is met with a large protest on campus.
Orange and Chatham County School Districts Celebrate Performance Milestones for 2025-26 Year
The Orange County, Chatham County and Chapel Hill-Carrboro City school districts are celebrating positive performance trends demonstrated in the latest accountability report from the North Carolina Department of Public Instruction. All 13 Orange County Schools earned a performance grade of “C” or higher for the 2025-26 school year, marking the first time since 2017 that […]
Orange County Sheriff: Student Assaults Staff Members at Partnership Academy
A School Resource Officer from the Orange County Sheriff’s Office detained a student at Hillsborough’s Partnership Academy Tuesday after the student allegedly assaulted two staff members, per a release. The sheriff’s office says the SRO will now coordinate with the North Carolina Department of Juvenile Justice and Delinquency Prevention regarding legal consequences. After the assault, […]
Speaking of Schools: National Principal of the Year Jason Johnson
Orange High School Principal and National Principal of the Year Jason Johnson joined 97.9 The Hill's Andrew Stuckey in studio on Monday, August 3. He discussed his recollection of receiving the National Principal of the Year award at a ceremony in Washington, D.C. He also recounted the work that has earned him accolades, including his decision to return to Orange High School after a prior stint leading that building, and more.
Former Orange High School Counselor Charged Over Indecent Liberties With Students
A former high school counselor, who recently resigned from Orange County Schools amid investigation into her conduct, turned herself into authorities on Thursday.
Local Government Meetings: June 15-19, 2026
This week in local government: a proposed AI moratorium in Durham and a board appointment (maybe) in Chatham County.
Here’s What You Need to Know Before CHCCS, Orange County High Schools’ 2026 Graduations
Chapel Hill-Carrboro City Schools and Orange County Schools will celebrate its high school graduates across three days this weekend. 
Following Budget Talks, Orange County Commissioners Prepare to Raise Taxes for More School Funding
Voicing a desire to better fund its public school systems, the Orange County Board of Commissioners is poised to further raise taxes in FY27.
Facing Pressures In All Directions, Orange County Commissioners Near Budget Decision
Orange County Commissioners are holding a public hearing on next year's budget Thursday, May 28, with major decisions yet to be made.
Orange County Government, Local School Districts Try to Do 'More With Less' Amid State Funding Uncertainty
Orange County's school districts will likely not get the full extent of their proposed budgets for the upcoming school year.
›