The Orange County Board of Commissioners meeting on Tuesday night at times felt like a funeral service for the Durham-Orange Light Rail Transit project.

Commissioners gave, in their own words, a “post-mortem” on the light rail, after which the commissioners unanimously voted to discontinue work on the project.

This is one step in a series of votes to formally end the light rail project. The GoTriangle Board of Trustees voted last week to recommend to Durham and Orange Counties that they discontinue their efforts. Now, Durham commissioners are scheduled to vote next on April 8.

Commissioner Mark Marcoplos, who is the county’s representative on the GoTriangle board, gave a list of several factors he said contributed to the project’s failure. He pointed first to “disingenuous” project partners Duke University and North Carolina Railroads. The state legislature also made things difficult, Marcoplos said, and so did the federal government shutdown, which set the project back two months at a crucial time in its development with the recent partial government shutdown.

“One or two of those problems would have been surmountable,” Marcoplos said, “but it was a cascade of fairly arbitrary circumstances that led us to this point.”

Marcoplos said that the influx of people to the Triangle was going to continue, with or without the light rail, and the need remained for a comprehensive regional transit plan. Commission chair Penny Rich agreed.

“We have a problem; we need to keep moving people around. And if we keep growing, we have got to really think about how we are going to do that.”

Commissioner Earl McKee, a longtime critic of the project, said any future transit planning needs to better prioritize the needs of Orange County. He said Tuesday that the light rail would have left many county residents, especially those in rural areas, behind.

“I would never agree to go back to an agreement that allows anything other than Orange County’s Board to control the direction of where we are going to go on transportation,” McKee said. “We need to have control over our own destiny.”

After Tuesday’s vote, county staff will come together in the next month to amend the Orange County Transit Plan and reallocate the $149.5 million Orange County set aside for the now-defunct light rail project. Deputy County Manager Travis Myren said a new transit plan would start from scratch and could include Durham or other counties as part of an agreement around regional transportation.

But the process for the transit plan will start again from the beginning and need public input and new agreements from county partners to move forward.

Related Stories
‹
Orange County Commissioners Vote to Move Forward with Light Rail Project
After a long night of discussion and debate, the Board of Orange County Commissioners passed a memorandum of understanding that says the county will look into the possibility of paying an additional 40 million dollars over a 10-year period towards the Durham-Orange Light Rail Project. County attorney John Roberts said the memorandum does not require […]
GoTriangle Exploring Light Rail Future Without Duke Cooperative Agreement
GoTriangle officials told Orange County Commissioners on Tuesday night that the organization was so close to completing the engineering phase of the Durham – Orange Light Rail Transit project that construction beginning to move private utilities could being late this calendar year, before picking up in earnest in 2020. But that is assuming the light […]
GoTriangle Invites Duke to Mediation Over Light Rail Concerns
Transit officials are hoping one last olive branch can get the Durham – Orange Light Rail transit project back on track. GoTriangle released a letter on Tuesday that was sent to Duke University president Vincent Price on Monday. The letter comes after Duke announced it would not enter into a cooperative agreement with the transit […]
Orange County Voting on Additional DOLRT Stop Tuesday Night
The Orange County Board of Commissioners will vote on an additional stop being added to the Durham-Orange Light Rail proposal Tuesday night. Any additional stop being considered for the Durham-Orange Light Rail line causes the proposal to go back before the Orange County Board of Commissioners and other stakeholder bodies. GoTriangle staff brought two potential […]
Orange County Facing April 30 Deadline for Light Rail Funding
After Orange County committed in December to consider spending an additional $40 million over a 10-year period on the Durham-Orange Light Rail project, the commissioners once again have a major decision to make. The Federal Transit Administration is looking for additional documentation to ensure the project can continue as planned. GoTriangle general manager Jeff Mann […]
Work Continuing on Durham-Orange County Light Rail Amid Budgetary Concerns
GoTriangle is continuing working with local universities, health care institutions, government and the private sector to continue its plans for a Light Rail that would potentially travel between Durham and Orange Counties – even while budgetary concerns remain due to a cap on light rail spending put in place by the General Assembly. After receiving […]
GoTriangle 'Optimistic' Light Rail Funding Will Be Restored After Surprise Alternate Cap from Senate
The Durham – Orange Light Rail project may not be out of the woods quite yet under the budget proposals from the North Carolina legislature. The 17-mile rail proposal has an estimated price tag of nearly $1.6 billion and would be funded at 50 percent with federal dollars, 25 percent from the state and 25 […]
House Budget Clears Path for Durham-Orange Light Rail
As part of the $22 billion budget proposal that has made its way through the North Carolina House, the cap on light rail spending that was put in place at the end of the long legislative session last year has been removed. The budget passed its third reading in the House on Thursday by a […]
Light Rail Project Clears Hurdle
The light rail project connecting Chapel Hill and Durham has cleared a major hurdle. Natalie Murdock is the spokesperson on the project for GoTriangle. She says the Federal Transit Administration signed off on the Draft Environmental Impact Statement last Thursday. “Essentially, this allows us to go forward and show the public everything that we’ve been working […]
Orange County Formally Votes to End Light Rail
The Orange County Board of Commissioners meeting on Tuesday night at times felt like a funeral service for the Durham-Orange Light Rail Transit project. Commissioners gave, in their own words, a “post-mortem” on the light rail, after which the commissioners unanimously voted to discontinue work on the project. This is one step in a series […]
›