HILLSBOROUGH- A second attempt to streamline Orange County’s animal control ordinance hit a roadblock Tuesday as commissioners, residents and animal services staffers wrangled over what it means to be a watchdog.

“I’m not sure that we need a definition of watchdog, per se, but I think we need a definition of an animal that’s on its own property, minding its own business, when a human being comes on the property who is not minding their own business,” said Board Chair Barry Jacobs.

The current ordinance defines a watchdog as any dog that barks or threatens to bite an intruder, but Staff Attorney Annette Moore said that’s too broad.

“It’s meaningless, because there’s no prohibition in the ordinance against anybody having a dog that barks at a person,” Moore told the board.

Animal Services Advisory Board Vice-Chair Michelle Walker said the inclusion of the term in the ordinance only causes confusion when someone gets bitten.

“That’s the public safety concern,” said Walker. “We want to identify dogs that have shown propensity to bite unprovoked by someone who is not on property with any ill intent.”

But commissioners including Mark Dorosin argued that the ordinance needs some added flexibility on the question of who’s liable when a dog bites a trespasser.

“Under the current ordinance there’s a blanket ‘no-liability’ for an owner if a person comes onto their land, and I think the concern of the dog owners is that they don’t want the thing turned 180 degrees so there’s strict liability if their dogs bites anyone,” said Dorosin. “So what we have is these two extreme positions being staked out, neither of which I think serves the interests of the county.”

The ordinance would have required a unanimous vote to pass on the first reading. Instead, the board tabled the item for discussion in two weeks. At that time, commissioners say they want Animal Services staffers to come back with new ideas.

“There’s some galaxy of issues dealing with ‘watchdog’ and ‘trespass’ that I think we’re all asking you to try and address,” said Jacobs. “I think we need more clarity.”

The board was largely in favor of other portions of the new ordinance, including a plan to create a formal appeal process for residents whose animals have been deemed dangerous or vicious.

Commissioners will revisit the animal control ordinance on October 15.

Related Stories
‹
Orange County Reports Third Rabies Case of 2021
Orange County Animal Services has reported its third rabies case of the year following an incident in Hillsborough. On December 5, a Hillsborough resident discovered a skunk in an outdoor enclosure with his dog. After unsuccessful attempts to scare the skunk away, he killed the skunk and called Animal Control. Animal Control arrived and removed […]
Wolf-Dog Hybrids Loose in Orange County, Trapping Efforts Underway
Several wolf-hybrid dogs are at large in Orange County after escaping from their enclosure, according to Orange County Animal Services.
BoCC Puts Animal Ordinance Change On Hold
I think the process was wrong..."
New Statewide Transport Program Aims to Increase Shelter Dog Adoptions Across North Carolina
A new intrastate transport program is seeking to improve adoption rates for shelter dogs by moving them to areas with higher demand. 
Orange County Reports Positive Rabies Test on Raccoon in Hillsborough
Orange County Animal Services has reported a positive rabies test on a deceased raccoon found in Hillsborough. On February 3, animal control received a call from a resident reporting their dog coming into contact with the raccoon near Joseph Road, located north of downtown Hillsborough off of Walnut Grove Church Road. The raccoon was retrieved […]
Orange County's First Rabies Case of 2025 Reported in Chapel Hill
The Orange County Animal Services department confirmed its first positive rabies case of the new calendar year this week in Chapel Hill.
Positive Rabies Test Reported on Raccoon in Carrboro, Orange County's 8th in 2024
Orange County Animal Services announced a positive rabies test for a raccoon in Carrboro on Tuesday morning. OCAS reports the case originated on Dec. 23 in an altercation involving the raccoon and a group of dogs outdoors near Lilac Drive. Animal services removed the raccoon for testing and discovered rabies. This is the third reported […]
Rabid Bat Reported Near Cedar Ridge High School in Hillsborough
Orange County Animal Services has reported a positive rabies test on a bat found in Hillsborough. A release from OCAS says the incident occurred on Thursday, November 7 near the intersection of Arbor Lane and New Grady Brown School Road, just west of Cedar Ridge High School. According to the release, a person came into […]
Positive Rabies Tests from Stray Cats Mark 6th and 7th in Orange County for 2024
Orange County Animal Services received its sixth positive rabies case of the year on Monday, this time stemming from an outdoor cat.
Positive Rabies Test Reported on Skunk in Hillsborough; 5th This Year
Orange County Animal Services has announced a positive rabies test on a skunk in Hillsborough. According to a release from OCAS, an altercation involving the skunk and multiple people occurred in the vicinity of Orange Grove Road and New Grady Brown School Road, next to Interstate 40 and Cedar Ridge High School, on September 25. […]
›