A portion of a 2019 North Carolina law designed to toughen mail-in absentee ballot rules following a fraud investigation in a congressional race went too far and is unconstitutional, a lawsuit filed on Wednesday contends.

Lawyers for Advance Carolina, a group that works in part to get African Americans out to vote in the state, said the new limits on who can help someone fill out requests to obtain a ballot violate state constitutional protections. The group wants enforcement blocked of what it calls the new “application organizing ban.”

The ban not only denies “voters valuable assistance in obtaining absentee ballots to facilitate their political participation, but it also infringes on the core political speech and associational activities of organizations and citizens working to increase voter turnout,” attorney Burton Craige wrote in the lawsuit filed in Wake County Superior Court.

The law was approved by the state House and Senate in October with only one “no” vote and signed by Democratic Gov. Roy Cooper.

Supporters of the legislation say it attempted to combat illegal ballot “harvesting,” which occurred in the 9th Congressional District campaign in 2018, according to evidence collected in a State Board of Elections probe. The investigation led to a new 9th District election last September.

The traditional absentee ballot process remained largely the same in the new law: a registered voter fills out a ballot request form that gets sent to the elections board in their home county. The county board then sends an absentee “application” and a clean ballot to the voter, who then fills out both.

While the measure increased criminal penalties for people who attempt to sell or destroy others’ completed absentee ballots, Advance Carolina said it made no sense to further restrict who could help fill out a ballot request to only the voter or a close relative. The collection of completed or partially completed ballots was the key element in the absentee ballot probe in the 9th District, focused on a Republican operative in Bladen County.

An outside individual had been previously able to help with the ballot request form, which allowed political groups to implement get-out-the-vote efforts. Now, the lawsuit says, there are now “greater restrictions on completing absentee ballot applications than it does for filling out and submitting absentee ballots.” This amounts to an unconstitutional burden on the right to vote, according to Advance Carolina.

The state and the State Board of Elections are among the defendants in the case. Joseph Kyzer, a spokesman for House Speaker Tim Moore, told WRAL-TV the bipartisan law doesn’t prevent any organization from encouraging absentee voting and will be defended by legislators.

The plaintiffs’ lawyers also include several from a Washington, D.C., law firm that helped represent Democrat Dan McCready, who ran unsuccessfully for the 9th District seat in 2018 and 2019. He and his campaign weren’t accused of any wrongdoing.

Related Stories
‹
North Carolina Governor Adds 2 GOP Members to Election Board
North Carolina’s governor has appointed two Republicans to the State Board of Elections to replace predecessors who resigned amid pushback over absentee ballot procedures they had voted to support. Gov. Roy Cooper, a Democrat, has appointed Carr McLamb, a lawyer who previously worked at two state agencies; and Tommy Tucker, a former legislator, to the […]
NC Republicans Try Again to Dislodge Voter ID From Courts
North Carolina Republican legislative leaders are trying to reinstate the implementation of a voter photo identification requirement. Attorneys for the GOP legislators have filed a motion asking trial court judges to lift an order that blocked enforcement of a 2018 law that laid out the rules for voter photo ID while a state lawsuit filed […]
North Carolina Absentee Ballots Are Being Distributed Following 2-Week Delay
Written by THE ASSOCIATED PRESS North Carolina counties started distributing absentee ballots Tuesday for the November general election to those who requested them, roughly two weeks later than anticipated as a legal challenge forced delays. Election officials in all 100 counties planned to mail out the first ballots to regular state residents starting Tuesday. Ballots to […]
North Carolina’s Absentee Ballot Release Was Delayed by RFK Jr. Ruling, but Will Begin This Week
North Carolina's first absentee ballots for the November election will be distributed starting this week, the State Board of Elections said.
Rep. Robert Reives Talks Kamala Harris, Roy Cooper, and More
NC House Minority Leader and District 54 Representative Robert Reives spoke with 97.9 The Hill's Andrew Stuckey on Friday, July 26. He discussed the change at the top of the Democratic ticket for president, telling the story of how he learned the news of Biden stepping down after having his phone on airplane mode for a long flight. He described the feelings of optimism that followed the string of endorsements for Vice President Harris, and talked about what happens next. He discussed Gov. Roy Cooper as a possible Vice President, and more.
Here Are the Important Dates to Know for 2023 Election Season in Orange, Chatham Counties
What are the dates and deadlines Orange and Chatham County voters should know for the 2023 municipal election cycle?
North Carolina Republicans Seek Control Over State and Local Election Boards Ahead of 2024
Written by GARY D. ROBERTSON Republicans who control the North Carolina legislature with veto-proof majorities are close to wrestling supervision of elections from the governor and the governor’s party — almost always the Democrats for over a century. A bill that could reach Gov. Roy Cooper’s desk this week would, among other changes, take away from […]
North Carolina Governor Vetoes Election Bill, Sparking Override Showdown With GOP Supermajority
Written by HANNAH SCHOENBAUM North Carolina Gov. Roy Cooper vetoed a sweeping Republican elections bill Thursday that would end a grace period for voting by mail and make new allowances for partisan poll observers. In a video message, the Democratic governor accused legislative Republicans of using their slim veto-proof majorities to execute “an all-out assault on the right […]
Elections Board, Absentee, Early Vote Changes Heard by North Carolina Senate Panel
Written by GARY D. ROBERTSON North Carolina Republican senators began on Wednesday to attempt to advance wide-ranging voting measures addressing early and absentee balloting and transferring control over the state election board from Democratic Gov. Roy Cooper to legislative leaders. The sponsors of the two measures pitched to a Senate committee said they’re designed to […]
N. Carolina GOP Pushes To Move Up Absentee Ballot Deadline
Written by HANNAH SCHOENBAUM North Carolina voters who turn in their absentee ballots after polls close on Election Day could see them tossed out under a bill advancing in the state House. A GOP-sponsored bill that passed 14-7 Tuesday in the House Election Law Committee would remove the state’s three-day grace period after an election […]
›