The deed to one of the oldest buildings in Hillsborough may be changing hands as the municipal government drops eminent domain proceedings against the owner of the Colonial Inn.
A settlement was reached last month regarding the historic hotel that opened in 1838 on West King Street and operated for over 130 years before falling into a state of disrepair.
Real estate mogul Francis Henry is now permitted to sell the property that he bought at a town auction in 2002, with Mayor Tom Stevens having endorsed the anticipated sale.
“They’re going to put the Colonial Inn on the market; we have withdrawn the eminent domain request, and that means it’s free and clear for private ownership to come in,” relayed Stevens. “The main thing we want to see is this property restored.”
The agreement also stipulates that the municipal government may reinitiate its efforts to acquire the property if a sale is not made within a reasonable amount of time.
“The town does have an option to refile the eminent domain; we have one year to do so,” he noted. “We’re certainly going to hold off on that until that year is up.
According to Stevens, this solution is agreeable to all parties involved, as it keeps both Henry and town officials from having to spend undue amounts of time in court.
“I think all parties would love to see some kind of settlement — which is what we have — in lieu of a really nasty court battle, and I think this is a very good compromise,” he opined.
Stevens also recounted the details surrounding an unorthodox clause in the settlement contract that requires both parties to speak publicly on local media outlets that include WCHL.
“[They] just want to be able to sit down together [with us] and go to media outlets and mentioned [WCHL] specifically,” he explained. “We said, ‘Well, of course; we’re happy to do that.'”
The Colonial Inn was purchased by Henry for $400,000, but appraisers at UNC-Chapel Hill estimate that the property needs renovations that may cost over $3 million.
Prospective buyers will be required to take the property through a zoning process before closing on it, as it currently retains its classification as a residential building.
Photo by Helen Woolard.
Related Stories
‹

Investors Snap Up Growing Share of US Homes as Traditional Buyers Struggle To Afford OneReal estate investors are snapping up a bigger share of U.S. homes on the market as rising prices and high borrowing costs freeze out others.

While New National Real Estate Rules Go Into Effect, Local Brokers Say They Expect Little ChangeOne month ago, the national real estate industry implemented new rules that caused changes. For some local brokers, it's business as usual.

Trump Spars With Judge and Slams NY Attorney General at a Trial That Imperils His Real Estate EmpireWritten by JILL COLVIN, MICHAEL R. SISAK, JENNIFER PELTZ and ERIC TUCKER A defiant Donald Trump sparred with a New York judge and slammed the state attorney general suing him Monday, using the witness stand at his civil fraud trial to defend his riches and lash out at a case that imperils his real estate empire. The […]

Housing Market Chills as Mortgage Rates, Prices Scare BuyersWritten by KEN SWEET, MICHAEL CASEY and ALEX VEIGA It’s the summer that cooled off the housing market. Rising mortgage rates have combined with already high home prices to discourage would-be buyers. Mortgage applications have declined sharply. Sales of previously occupied homes have fallen for five straight months, during what is generally the busiest time […]
![]()
US Home Prices Surge 18.4% In OctoberWritten by PAUL WISEMAN U.S. home prices surged again in October as the housing market continues to boom in the wake of last year’s coronavirus recession. The S&P CoreLogic Case-Shiller 20-city home price index, out Tuesday, climbed 18.4% in October from a year earlier. The gain marked a slight deceleration from a 19.1% year-over-year increase […]
![]()
On Air Today: Aaron Nelson and Pam Hemminger on the Real Estate ForumFollowing the Chamber of Commerce's recent forum on the real estate landscape, President and CEO of the Chamber Aaron Nelson, as well as Chapel Hill Mayor Pam Hemminger, speak with 97.9 The Hill's Brighton McConnell about top takeaways.

Carrboro Police Investigating Shooting at Apartment Complex; 1 InjuredThe Carrboro Police Department is investigating a shooting at an apartment complex that left one person severely injured Saturday morning. A release from the department said officers arrived at the Crest at West End Apartment complex off North Carolina Highway 54 after a shooting occurred around 5:15 a.m. Upon arrival, officers found one male subject […]

Eller Capital Rebranding Long-time Carrboro Apartments to West End FlatsThe Crest at West End apartment community in Carrboro is being changed to the West End Flats, as Eller Capital Partners works to update the units inside and out. The Crest at West End Apartments is the sixth property in the Chapel Hill-Carrboro market that Eller Capital has purchased. The firm, which is headquartered in […]
![]()
Rams Plaza Sells for $21.55 MillionChapel Hill retail center Rams Plaza off Fordham Boulevard has sold to new owners for more than $21 million, following $2 million renovations made to the plaza. This purchase is the first out-of-state retail investment that the buyer, an affiliate of Austin Sumner Properties of Athens, Georgia, has made, according to the Triangle Business Journal. […]
![]()
Hillsborough Mayor Discusses Anticipated Sale of Colonial InnThe deed to one of the oldest buildings in Hillsborough may be changing hands as the municipal government drops eminent domain proceedings against the owner of the Colonial Inn. A settlement was reached last month regarding the historic hotel that opened in 1838 on West King Street and operated for over 130 years before falling […]
›