More than three months after it was taken, the stolen sign for the shut-down Surplus Sid’s in Carrboro returned to the former shop.

Chip Hoppin, co-owner of The Merch on Lloyd Street, shared a post to social media Wednesday morning saying he passed the former military surplus, costume and knick-knack store on East Main Street around 10 a.m. and happened to see the sign leaning up against the building. It had a note attached to it, which read “I am very sorry. I didn’t know how [important] the sign was.”

For years, the sign stood between two wooden stakes at the entrance of Surplus Sid’s to catch the attention of travelers on East Main Street. The mystery of the its disappearance began in March, after it had been removed and was simply leaning up against the storefront. Both Hoppin and TriangleBlogBlog shared that Surplus Sid’s founder Barry Keith wanted it back to commemorate the store he ran for more than three decades. The shop closed in Sept. 2025 as Keith transitioned to retirement and to focus on his health — news drastic enough to where a GoFundMe campaign raised more than $3,500 to help cover bills and at-home care for Keith.

For now, Orange County community members are celebrating on social media that the wooden, red and white Surplus Sid’s sign is back at the empty store. Keith still owns the building and property at 309 East Main Street, according to Orange County land records, and there is no public indication of what the future of the space may be.

Featured photos via Chip Hoppin.

Chapelboro.com does not charge subscription fees, and you can directly support our efforts in local journalism here. Want more of what you see on Chapelboro? Let us bring free local news and community information to you by signing up for our newsletter.

 

Related Stories
‹
Carrboro Businesses Pledge Donation Days to Support The ArtsCenter for Its 50th Anniversary
The ArtsCenter announced a lineup of businesses participating in "Artstober" to help raise money for and spread awareness of its operations.
Cigar Smoke Lawsuit Raises Caution for Carrboro's South Green Businesses
In Carrboro, Coronato Pizza is suing the neighboring Oasis Cigar Lounge and its South Green landlord over effects from secondhand smoke.
Carrboro: Greensboro Street Resurfacing to Improve Bicycle Lanes, Impact Evening Traffic
Starting Sunday June 14, a Carrboro resurfacing project will close Greensboro Street from Braxton Foushee Street to Oak Avenue most evenings.
CHCCS High Schools Win State Championships in Women's Lacrosse, Women's Soccer
Two local high schools each took home state championships last weekend. Chapel Hill High School took home the North Carolina 7A championship in women’s lacrosse, while Carrboro High won the 4A championship in women’s soccer. View this post on Instagram View this post on Instagram Chapel Hill High won the women’s lacrosse title, its first […]
Carrboro Man Arrested, Charged With Sexual Exploitation of a Minor
The Orange County Sheriff’s Office arrested a Carrboro man Monday and has charged him with multiple counts of sexual exploitation. 42-year-old Michael Robert Westendorf faces six felony warrants for second-degree and four counts of third-degree sexual exploitation of a minor. Second-degree exploitation includes duplicating material containing a visual representation of a minor engaged in sexual […]
Local Government Meetings: June 1-5, 2026
This week in local government: budget decisions for Orange County, Carrboro, and Durham, and the final vote on a CHCCS school closure.
'We Are Extremely Concerned': Carrboro, Hillsborough Weigh Tough Budget Choices
Tough budget decisions are looming in Carrboro and Hillsborough, where officials have to choose between higher taxes and major cuts.
Latest Community Survey Shows High Level of Satisfaction Among Carrboro Residents
The latest Carrboro Community Survey shows a high level of satisfaction among town residents. The biennial survey, the results of which were presented to the Carrboro Town Council during its May 19 meeting, shows 96 percent of respondents rated the town as an excellent or good place to live. In addition, 93 percent of Carrboro […]
CHCCS Announces Leadership Changes At Carrboro High And Culbreth Middle Schools
This week, Chapel Hill-Carrboro City Schools announced that two of its current principals will swap schools in the upcoming academic year.
Garbage Collection, Local Transit and More: How Memorial Day Will Impact Local Services
The observation of Memorial Day Monday, May 25 will affect local government services around the Orange County community. Here’s what residents can expect: Town of Chapel Hill Memorial Day is an official town holiday. Most town and other administrative offices will be closed. Residential trash will not be collected on Monday, with the make-up day […]
›