Orange County Judge: Normal Court Proceedings Present Public Health Challenges

While the state prepares to enter Phase 1 on Friday, there are still many aspects of state government operating on reduced capacity. That includes North Carolina’s courts, which are determining when to begin full proceedings again.

North Carolina Chief Justice Cheri Beasley pushed back most court proceedings until at least June 1, giving the court system more time to devise a strategy of how to return. But like most places in our community, its normal setup will have to change to accommodate social distancing.

Orange County Superior Court Judge Allen Baddour recently spoke with 97.9 The Hill’s Aaron Keck. Like many courts in the state, he said Orange County’s have remained open during this time but are only handling the most serious of cases.

“We have a constitutional duty to keep the courts open and that’s a really important obligation for our citizens,” he said. “It’s not necessarily making sure a person’s traffic ticket is dealt within 30 days, it’s more pressing matters.”

But when considering how to handle more and more cases as the state reopens, Baddour said plenty of challenges arise. He said with how many people are typically in a courtroom, it would be difficult to properly keep six feet apart if everyone is present for a case.

“How do we address both aspects of this intersection the courts lay in,” the judge posed, “between public health and open courts? And how does that actually happen in the moment, in a particular hearing?”

For now, the efforts to address that have been significantly decreased amounts of people in courtrooms and using more virtual communication for cases. The United States Supreme Court, for example, is hearing oral arguments over the phone this week for the first time ever.

In Orange County, Baddour said it’s not been without some obstacles and breaks in tradition.

“Probably the most challenging [thing],” he said, “is getting people on board with addressing cases in a Zoom-like platform. People are so used to being in court, seeing and hearing, being able to literally touch everyone there in the room.”

The judge said, though, some aspects of court procedures have become more efficient. He said he could see permanent changes coming thanks to this, like handling more matters or filings online.

“That’s sort of where I see the future going,” said Baddour. “If there’s a silver lining in all this for the court system, for me, that’s it: our ability to work faster and more efficiently, but still fairly and in a way that can save folks’ money in a court process.”

The courts are not listed in Governor Roy Cooper’s three phases of reopening the state. If public health trends continue, North Carolina could enter Phase 2 as early as May 22.

Chapelboro.com does not charge subscription fees. You can support local journalism and our mission to serve the community. Contribute today – every single dollar matters.

‹

Orange County Courthouse Closes Due to COVID-19 Exposure

The Orange County Courthouse will temporarily close to the public following “an exposure” to COVID-19. Court officials for the Hillsborough facility announced the closure on Tuesday, citing a recent threat to the public and court employees’ safety from the coronavirus. According to a release from the North Carolina Judicial Branch, those working at the courthouse […]

Ethics Probe Into North Carolina Justice’s Comments Continues After Federal Court Refuses to Halt It

Associate Justice Anita Earls sued the North Carolina Judicial Standards Commission in August and argued she used her First Amendment rights.

After Review, Orange County Says Boom in Hillsborough Was 2.2 Magnitude Earthquake

UPDATE: On Friday, the Orange County government said the U.S. Geological Survey completed a review and determined the loud noise ultimately was a small earthquake.

Nieman Sworn In as Orange, Chatham County's District Attorney

The 2022 election cycle brought about many changes among our community’s representation in the state and federal governments. But there was also a big change for Orange and Chatham County at district attorney.

Teenage Suspect in Orange County Double-Murder Makes First Superior Court Appearance

Issiah Ross, who is accused of killing two other teenagers in rural Orange County, made his first appearance in superior court.

Town of Hillsborough Unveils New Logo, Sticks With 'Iconic Clocktower' Symbol

The Town of Hillsborough unveiled its new logo on Wednesday — a reworking of the Historic Orange County Courthouse’s clock tower, which has been a symbol of Hillsborough for many years. The new logo, which was designed by Alison Duncan of Duncan Design in Pennsylvania, was selected by the Hillsborough Board of Commissioners last spring and […]

Report: Charges Dismissed for 2 Accused of Helping Take Down Silent Sam

Two of the remaining people facing charges in the toppling of the Confederate statue known as Silent Sam saw their charges dismissed by the court system this week. According to a report from The News & Observer on Wednesday, the charges for Raul Arce Jimenez and Shawn Birchfield-Finn were dropped due to the local court system working to […]

NC Supreme Court Removing Portrait of Slave Owner Ex-Justice

The North Carolina Supreme Court announced Tuesday that it will remove a portrait of a former chief justice from its courtroom who staunchly defended slavery and owned slaves himself. Thomas Ruffin, a slave owner in the 1800s, believed an owner’s power over his slave was absolute. He once wrote in a court ruling that slaveholders should not […]

Durham, Orange County Courts Reopen With Health Measures in Place

After more than two months of largely limited in-person operations, courthouses in both Orange County and Durham County reopened to proceedings on Monday. The order from state Chief Justice Cheri Beasley delaying or moving online many non-criminal proceedings began in mid-March at the onset of the coronavirus pandemic in North Carolina. Since then, courthouses have […]

Orange County Judge: Normal Court Proceedings Present Public Health Challenges

While the state prepares to enter Phase 1 on Friday, there are still many aspects of state government operating on reduced capacity. That includes North Carolina’s courts, which are determining when to begin full proceedings again. North Carolina Chief Justice Cheri Beasley pushed back most court proceedings until at least June 1, giving the court […]

›