North Carolina judges refused on Thursday to block a witness requirement for mail-in absentee ballots this fall that’s already been scaled down by legislators to address COVID-19 health concerns.

The three judges rejected unanimously a request for an injunction by registered voters in a lawsuit filed in July that challenged the state law that one witness sign a person’s ballot return envelope.

More than 600,000 North Carolina absentee ballot requests — dramatically higher compared to 2016 — already have been received for the November election, as many with health concerns prefer not to vote in person. The first ballots will be mailed to registered voters on Friday.

The voters who sued — each with pre-existing health conditions — said the one-witness requirement demanded close contact that would force them to choose between their health and the right to vote.

The judges wrote Thursday that the plaintiffs were unlikely to win at trial. Even if it appeared they could succeed, the ruling said, making a change would require replacements for ballot envelopes and voter guides that have already cost hundreds of thousands of dollars.

“Such a process will create delays in mailing ballots for all North Carolinians voting by absentee ballot … and would likely lead to voter confusion,” read the ruling signed by Superior Court Judges Alma Hinton, Robert Bell and Thomas Lock.

State law usually requires two witness signatures, but the General Assembly agreed in June to reduce it to help people who may be at a higher risk for the coronavirus.

Photo via AP Photo/Matt Rourke.

Related Stories
‹
Judge Delays Ruling on North Carolina Absentee Ballot Procedure
A federal judge leveled sharp criticism on Wednesday against a procedure giving North Carolina voters more leeway to fix witness problems on absentee ballots, but declined to immediately rule in a tangle of election-related lawsuits. U.S. District Judge William Osteen, who’s presiding over three related cases, said he aims to issue a written ruling early […]
NC Halts Plan to Resolve Ballot Issue With Voter Affidavits
Pending a legal review, the North Carolina State Board of Elections is suspending steps to allow voters to correct absentee ballots lacking the required witness signature by signing an affidavit. In a memo sent to county elections officials on Thursday, the state board’s executive director, Karen Brinson Bell, ordered them to hit the brakes on […]
Ballot Selfies Are Still Illegal in North Carolina — Even At Home
North Carolinians have been submitting absentee ballot requests more this election cycle than usual, with the coronavirus pandemic causing concern for in-person options of voting. State data showed close to 1 million mail-in ballots have been requested by registered voters who either cannot or do not wish to go to their polling station. Many people […]
Early Vote Shows Signs of Black Voters' Shift to Mail Voting
Shirley Dixon-Mosley had never sent a ballot through the mail. She always treasured casting her ballot in person. But for November’s election, she voted early and by mail because she didn’t want to take any chances. “I want to make sure my vote got in and it counted,” said the 75-year-old retired teacher’s aide in […]
Hundreds of Ballots Accepted as North Carolina Begins Voting
Hundreds of ballots were accepted in North Carolina on Tuesday, making the Tar Heel State the first in the nation to kick off voting in the November general election. County elections officials accepted 903 of the more than 606,000 ballots sent out to voters since Friday, as of 5:30 p.m. Tuesday. The numbers provided by […]
North Carolina Absentee Ballots Are Being Distributed Following 2-Week Delay
Written by THE ASSOCIATED PRESS North Carolina counties started distributing absentee ballots Tuesday for the November general election to those who requested them, roughly two weeks later than anticipated as a legal challenge forced delays. Election officials in all 100 counties planned to mail out the first ballots to regular state residents starting Tuesday. Ballots to […]
North Carolina’s Absentee Ballot Release Was Delayed by RFK Jr. Ruling, but Will Begin This Week
North Carolina's first absentee ballots for the November election will be distributed starting this week, the State Board of Elections said.
N. Carolina GOP Pushes To Move Up Absentee Ballot Deadline
Written by HANNAH SCHOENBAUM North Carolina voters who turn in their absentee ballots after polls close on Election Day could see them tossed out under a bill advancing in the state House. A GOP-sponsored bill that passed 14-7 Tuesday in the House Election Law Committee would remove the state’s three-day grace period after an election […]
N. Carolina Rights Groups Say GOP Bills Impede Voting Access
Written by GARY D. ROBERTSON Civil and voting rights groups Monday blasted election bills written by North Carolina Republicans and expected on the Senate floor this week, calling them another GOP attempt at voter suppression, especially of minority groups. Senate GOP leaders are advancing three measures, one of which would require mail-in absentee ballots be received by […]
Bill Moving up Absentee Deadline in NC Clears Senate Panel
Written by GARY D. ROBERTSON Mail-in absentee ballots in North Carolina would have to be received by the day of the election, under a Republican-backed bill that cleared a divided Senate committee on Wednesday. Current law says ballot envelopes must be postmarked by the election date and received within three days to be counted. That window […]
›