This column will add to a main problem with what is frequently written online:  I’m about to write my opinion of something about which I have almost no firsthand knowledge.  Kind of makes you want to click something else, doesn’t it?

I’m writing about the apparently pending transfer of Chapel Hill High School English teacher Anne Thompson.  I don’t know the teacher, I don’t have a child at the school, nor at her intended destination of Carrboro High.  I am not a member of any group that has fought the transfer nor have I been affiliated with the school board or administration in any way.  

Now that we’re clear on the many reasons I have absolutely no standing to have an opinion, here’s why I do:  I have a heart and compassion.  

From what I read on Chapelboro.com, this teacher is one year away from retirement and is still recovering from the death of her husband this past year.  Thompson has taught at CHHS for 26 years and to not be able to finish her career there seems as if it was decided by machines, not people.  If there were any reason to think we were talking about a teacher who was phoning it in, a lame duck, I certainly wouldn’t want any child at any school to receive less than the best but that doesn’t appear to be anyone’s concern about Anne Thompson.  

There are differing opinions/claims over whether this transfer has to do with some negative interactions Thompson may have had with the now-retired principal of CHHS.  Maybe it does. Maybe it doesn’t.  Maybe she did.  Maybe she didn’t.  He’s not there anymore.  She has one more year to teach.  Students seem to love her.  She’s being asked to learn new systems and a new curriculum in a place where she has no support system.  No one is at his/her most effective when new; it’s a trade-off that’s worth it when the change is one that’s going to build and vest over years.  That’s clearly not the case here.

So what’s the business case for this transfer?  If there is a business case for this, or an educational case, I’ve not heard it.  If there is a human case for it, I can’t find it.  Are our schools teaching children to be kind, to consider all circumstances, to look beyond the obvious?  Or are we teaching them to be rigid and punitive?  In my uneducated view of this case, there’s a beautiful opportunity for school system leadership to show the strength inherent in flexibility.  That would be some savvy spending of power!

Agree, disagree?  Leave a comment below or write to me at Donnabeth@Chapelboro.com

Related Stories
‹
Thompson's Exit
The saga of teacher Anne Thompson is coming to an end.  She will be leaving Chapel Hill-Carrboro City Schools in a few weeks, several months shy of her planned retirement.   If you’ve followed her saga, you know Thompson is not ending her career where she spent much of it, having been involuntarily transferred from […]
Follow-up Questions: Towing, Teachers, & Opportunity Cost
Word that Chapel Hill is going to continue the legal fight and appeal a judge’s ruling against a planned cell phone ban (including hands-free use) and a towing ordinance prompts a few questions: First of all, I keep hearing and reading that downtown businesses must use towing companies and aggressive towing tactics in order to […]
Fighting This Transfer
Dear Editor, My name is Bert Wartski.  As I await the Superior Court Hearing (August 17th at 2 pm at the Old Hillsborough Court House), I would like to take this opportunity to thank everyone who has written letters, given speeches, provided testimonials, talked about, Facebook-ed, and spent their time and energy to stop my […]
Cell Phones, Towing, & Teachers
Back in April I wrote about the Chapel Hill Town Council (CHTC) banning both handheld and hands-free cell phone use by drivers (with limited exceptions).   The point of my column then was not to root for distracted driving; it was to point out the pointless use of public (staff) time and money in defending […]
Teacher Transfers: Not Going Away
I have been writing this column for well over a year.  I’ve written on topics as mundane as grocery shopping and as critical as the state education budget.  I’ve written about highly emotional topics such as Amendment One.  Following the posting of some of these, I’ve heard from a few of you.  But after my […]
Questions for Superintendent Forcella
July 25, 2012 Dear Mr. Forcella, I have been following the debate regarding the involuntary transfers of Mr. Wartski and Mrs. Thompson. As a parent who had two children at Chapel Hill High, one in Mr. Wartski’s class and one in Mrs. Thompson’ class, I am confused and concerned about their transfers. Whatever your reasons, […]
Teaching Beyond the Classroom
This column will add to a main problem with what is frequently written online:  I’m about to write my opinion of something about which I have almost no firsthand knowledge.  Kind of makes you want to click something else, doesn’t it? I’m writing about the apparently pending transfer of Chapel Hill High School English teacher […]
›