A federal judge has ruled that North Carolina’s flagship public university may continue to consider race as a factor in its undergraduate admissions, ruling against a group that argued the practice disadvantaged white and Asian students.

U.S. District Judge Loretta Biggs ruled late Monday that the University of North Carolina has shown that it has a compelling reason to pursue a diverse student body and has demonstrated that measurable benefits come from that goal.

“In sum, the Court concludes that UNC has met its burden in demonstrating that it has a genuine and compelling interest in achieving the educational benefits of diversity,” Biggs wrote.

Students for Fair Admissions sued UNC in 2014, arguing that its admissions practices violated the equal protection cause of the Constitution and federal civil rights law. The group argued that UNC had gone too far in using race as a factor in admissions and had thus “intentionally discriminated against certain of (its) members on the basis of their race, color, or ethnicity.”

UNC countered that its admission practices are permissible under the law and that race-neutral alternatives would not allow it to achieve its diversity goals.

Students for Fair Admissions has pursued a similar lawsuit against Harvard, and is challenging an appellate denial in that case to the U.S. Supreme Court.

 

Photo via Johnny Andrews/UNC-Chapel Hill.

 

Related Stories
‹
Supreme Court Rules in UNC's Case Over Affirmative Action, Ends Race Consideration in Admissions
The U.S. Supreme Court announced its ruling in Students for Fair Admissions v. the University of North Carolina on Thursday, effectively ending decades of the practice of affirmative action in college admissions and a nearly ten-year lawsuit against the Chapel Hill school. The court’s conservative majority led the ruling that UNC’s, and Harvard’s in a […]
UNC Chancellor Speaks on Admissions Changes, New Financial Aid Plan Ahead of 2023-24 Classes
UNC officially opened up its doors to students who are living on campus this week, as it welcomes undergraduates back ahead of the start of classes on Monday. While the past academic year went relatively smoothly for the student body – compared to recent examples of Silent Sam controversies and the COVID-19 pandemic […]
UNC Organizations Plan to Still Champion Diversity in Wake of SCOTUS Ruling
Some UNC students and faculty groups say they will continue to push for diversity on campus despite the ruling against affirmative action.
Civil Rights Leaders Visit Chapel Hill, Advocate for SCOTUS Expansion
As the country awaits a ruling on the future of affirmative action in higher education, civil rights leaders visited Chapel Hill.
Supreme Court Holds Arguments in UNC Admissions Trial; Chancellor Proud of 'Strong Case'
UNC has maintained its argument that consideration of race in admissions promotes diversity and is better for its campus at large.
Cooper, Three Former NC Governors File Brief Supporting UNC Admission Practices
As the U.S. Supreme Court examines race-conscious admission practices at UNC, four North Carolina governors submitted a brief in support of the university and its practices. Current Governor Roy Cooper, as well as former Governors Mike Easley, Bev Purdue and Jim Hunt filed the amicus brief for an ongoing lawsuit against UNC that will see […]
Justices To Hear Challenge To Race in College Admissions
Written by MARK SHERMAN The conservative-dominated Supreme Court on Monday agreed to hear a challenge to the consideration of race in college admissions, adding another blockbuster case to a term with abortion, guns, religion and COVID-19 already on the agenda. The court said it will take up lawsuits claiming that Harvard University, a private institution, and the […]
UNC Set For Return to Court in Ongoing Admissions Lawsuit
The next chapter in a years-long lawsuit between UNC and an anti-affirmative action group is set to begin on Monday. The university looks to begin its defense in a case filed by Students for Fair Admissions Inc. against UNC’s admissions practices. Set to be held in the U.S. District Court for the Middle District of North Carolina, the […]
Freshman Classes Provide Glimpse of Affirmative Action Ruling’s Impact on Colleges
It is “too soon to see trends” from the affirmative action decision, said Rachelle Feldman, UNC’s vice provost for enrollment.
UNC Trustees Talk Affirmative Action, Accessibility at First Meeting of 2023-24
UNC Board of Trustees officially barred use of 'race, sex, color or ethnicity' in admissions, complying with Supreme Court case decision.
›