The law that replaced North Carolina’s notorious “bathroom bill” sports a new look but maintains LGBT discrimination and prevents transgender people from using restrooms matching their gender identity, according to a lawsuit Friday.

The lawsuit renews a high-profile legal battle that has thrust North Carolina into the center of the national debate over LGBT rights. The state took the “bathroom bill” off the books in late March after a yearlong backlash that hurt North Carolina’s reputation and caused businesses and sports leagues to back out of lucrative events and projects.

But lawyers from the American Civil Liberties Union and Lambda Legal said the replacement law, known as H.B. 142, continues the harms of its predecessor.

“Legislators were forced to rewrite the law,” ACLU lawyer Chris Brook told reporters Friday. “But make no mistake … H.B. 142 is a wolf in sheep’s clothing crafted to keep discrimination intact but sporting a new look.”

The compromise earlier this year between Republican legislative leaders and Democrats led by Gov. Roy Cooper eliminated the “bathroom bill” requirement that transgender people use restrooms in many public buildings corresponding to the sex on their birth certificates.

But the new law makes clear that that only the General Assembly — not local government or school officials — can make rules for public restrooms from now on. Local governments are also prohibited from enacting new nondiscrimination ordinances for workplaces, hotels and restaurants until December 2020.

“The vacuum purposefully created by H.B. 142 in effect maintains the ban of (the previous law) and encourages discrimination by both government and private entities and individuals,” the lawsuit said. “The law offers no guidance to anyone except by implication and makes it impossible for a reasonable person who is transgender to know which restroom they can legally use.”

The ambiguity is compounded by statements from Republican lawmakers that the new law would meet the same goals as the “bathroom bill,” according to the lawsuit. It cites a statement from House Speaker Tim Moore that the replacement law ensures that “persons of the opposite sex cannot go into designated multi-occupancy restrooms” and could face criminal trespassing charges.

A spokesman for Moore declined comment Friday.

The lawsuit argues that the law violates constitutional due process and equal protection rights, as well as federal laws against discrimination in workplaces and schools. The filing is a revamped version of an existing lawsuit that challenged the original “bathroom bill” in federal court. Most of the same parties remain from the previous complaint, with the addition of two new plaintiffs. Cooper is also named as a defendant.

A spokesman for Cooper, Ford Porter, said in an email Friday: “The governor’s ultimate goal is statewide LGBT protections, and he is going to continue working toward that.”

Since H.B. 142 went into effect earlier this year, sports leagues including the NBA, ACC and NCAA have said they would hold championship events in North Carolina again. The announcements of large business projects such as a 1,200-job expansion by Credit Suisse are a further indication that the state is repairing its image.

But the pain continues for transgender residents across the state, the plaintiffs said. For example, 28-year-old Joaquín Carcaño said he’s been unable to get an answer from his employer, the University of North Carolina, on which restrooms he’s permitted to use.

“We the trans community were used as bargaining chips in order to fix a damaged reputation,” Carcano said Friday, adding that the fight for LGBT rights didn’t end with the replacement law.

Madeline Goss, a 41-year-old transgender woman from Raleigh, said she fears for her safety under the current law: “There’s so much gray area that it creates this confusion.”

Related Stories
‹
NC 'Bathroom Bill' Sponsor Wins GOP Redo of Tainted Election
North Carolina’s most infamous political story lines of recent years are merging into a congressional race this summer that pits the architect of the state’s “bathroom bill” against a Democrat who was granted an electoral do-over after evidence of ballot fraud tainted his prior opponent’s campaign. State Sen. Dan Bishop topped nine other Republican candidates […]
Ban on North Carolina Trips Cramps NY State College Swimmers
A ban on New York state-funded travel to North Carolina is complicating matters for state college swimmers heading south for an NCAA championship. Democratic Gov. Andrew Cuomo signed an executive order in 2016 banning non-essential state-funded travel to North Carolina after lawmakers there voided a Charlotte ordinance that would have enabled transgender people to use […]
Judge Mulls Letting Bathroom Bill Fight Proceed
A federal judge needs time to consider whether transgender plaintiffs can proceed with a lawsuit challenging a North Carolina law that replaced the state’s “bathroom bill.” U.S. District Judge Thomas Schroeder heard arguments Monday over a request by Republican lawmakers to dismiss the lawsuit. He said at the end of the hearing that he would […]
North Carolina ‘Bathroom Bill’ Saga Lingers in Election Year
North Carolina is again an attractive location for big out-of-state corporations. The state no longer sits squarely in the crosshairs of culture wars over transgender rights. College basketball tournament games are back, after a one-year hiatus. But the saga of the state’s so-called bathroom bill hasn’t been forgotten, and many Republican incumbents who passed House […]
Groups Suing Over HB2 Asking for Expansion of Friday's Preliminary Injuntion
The LGBT rights groups suing the state of North Carolina are asking for broader relief than what was issued in a district court ruling on Friday regarding the state’s controversial House Bill 2. The law, which was passed in a whirlwind special session in March, has been criticized by advocacy groups as the worst piece […]
ACLU Responds to UNC System Memo Regarding HB2
The plaintiffs challenging North Carolina’s controversial House Bill 2 issued a statement saying they were “disappointed” in the leadership from the University of North Carolina after a memo was sent to the system Chancellors from new President Margaret Spellings. Spellings wrote in the memo that the legislation, which requires transgender individuals to use the bathroom […]
North Carolina Laws Curtailing Transgender Rights Prompt Less Backlash Than 2016 ‘Bathroom Bill'
Written by HANNAH SCHOENBAUM and GARY D. ROBERTSON Seven years ago, North Carolina became ground zero in the nationwide fight over transgender rights with the passage of a “bathroom bill” that galvanized culture warriors, canceled business projects and sporting events and influenced a gubernatorial race. And while a similarly Republican-controlled legislature’s enactment this week of a trio of […]
ACLU Sues North Carolina Over Harsher Riot Punishments
Written by HANNAH SCHOENBAUM Harsher punishments for violent protests in North Carolina are being challenged by a prominent civil rights group, which said in a federal lawsuit filed Tuesday that several parts of a new anti-riot law are unconstitutional. The North Carolina law was drawn up in response to protests against racial injustice and police […]
Former North Carolina Gov. McCrory Enters U.S. Senate Race
Written by GARY D. ROBERTSON Former Republican Gov. Pat McCrory on Wednesday announced he’ll run for the U.S. Senate in North Carolina, shaking up the calculus in the expanding field to succeed retiring Sen. Richard Burr with the entrance of a veteran of statewide politics. McCrory, who served as governor for four years through 2016, revealed […]
Settlement Expands Transgender Restroom Rights in N Carolina
A federal judge approved a legal settlement Tuesday affirming transgender people’s right to use restrooms matching their gender identity in many North Carolina public buildings. The consent decree between the state’s Democratic governor and transgender plaintiffs covers numerous state-owned buildings including facilities run by executive branch agencies that oversee the environment, transportation and Medicaid, among […]
›