North Carolina’s attorney general on Wednesday challenged regulators for allowing Duke Energy to start charging consumers hundreds of millions of dollars to clean up coal ash dumps and add a potential profit margin.

State Attorney General Josh Stein’s office said in a filing to the North Carolina Utilities Commission he considers its decision to pass along what could total billions of dollars for handling the potentially toxic chemicals in coal ash to be “unlawful, unjust, unreasonable, or unwarranted.”

Stein is appealing the commission’s February decision to the state Supreme Court.

The commission allowed the company’s Duke Energy Progress operating subsidiary to charge customers $232 million over five years for coal ash clean-up costs racked up already. Regulators simultaneously assessed the company a $30 million mismanagement penalty for what it called pervasive shortcomings in handling coal ash. The company pleaded guilty to federal environmental crimes in 2015 for its coal ash handling.

Thousands of consumers said in messages to the utilities commission they thought company shareholders should be forced to pay most of the clean-up costs.

Duke Energy spokeswoman Meredith Archie said the company sees the commission’s decision as fair to the company and consumers.

“While we do not agree with the order in its entirety, we believe the Commission’s decision is fair and gives customers the full benefits of cleaner and more reliable power, while keeping rates below the national average,” Archie said in an email.

Duke Energy, like other electric utilities around the country, is coping with cleaning up the accumulated tons of the residue left after burning coal for power for decades. Coal ash can contain mercury, arsenic and other toxic chemicals.

Stein is challenging the state utilities regulator’s decision to allow Duke Energy to charge consumers in part because of a state law directing the company to close all its ash pits by 2029. The commission decided the clean-up costs were reasonable “irrespective of Duke’s historical mismanagement, which included violations of previously-existing regulations and laws.”

Stein’s office said in its case filing that the commission shouldn’t have charged consumers for the cleanup because of “the greater weight of evidence which demonstrated that Duke knew of the risks of storing coal ash in unlined surface impoundments and failed to take timely and appropriate action to address those risks.”

The company this year agreed to pay a $156,000 penalty for polluting ground and surface waters with coal-ash waste leaking from pits at three power plants.

Related Stories
‹
Duke Energy Agrees to Remove Coal Ash in North Carolina
The state of North Carolina says it has secured an agreement with Duke Energy to excavate nearly 80 million tons of coal ash at six facilities. The Department of Environmental Quality said in a Thursday press release that it will be the largest coal ash cleanup in the nation’s history. It also settles various legal […]
Duke Energy Sued for 2014 Coal Ash Spill Environmental Harm
The federal, North Carolina and Virginia governments asked a court Thursday to declare the country’s largest electricity company liable for environmental damage from a leak five years ago that left miles of a river shared by the two states coated in hazardous coal ash. Government lawyers sought to have Charlotte-based Duke Energy declared responsible for […]
N Carolina, Duke Energy Contest Coal Ash Cost, Removal Scope
North Carolina’s environmental agency exceeded its authority by ordering Duke Energy Corp. to dig up all of its coal ash and move it from unlined storage sites where toxic chemicals have seeped into water supplies, the country’s largest electric company said Friday. Duke Energy said an administrative challenge to the state Department of Environmental Quality […]
Duke Energy to Contest N Carolina Coal Ash Excavation Order
The country’s largest electric company says it’s challenging an order by North Carolina’s environmental agency to excavate coal ash from all of its power plant sites in the state. Duke Energy Corp. said Thursday it will file an administrative appeal by May 1. The order could cut the risk of toxic chemicals leaking into water […]
Tests: Few Heavy Metals in River After Coal Plant Dam Burst
Despite the gray muck that fouled the Cape Fear River near a Wilmington power plant after Hurricane Florence, water tests so far show heavy metals contained in coal ash are within state standards, North Carolina environmental officials said Thursday. Water quality samples collected over four dates within two weeks of Florence crashing ashore a few […]
Duke Energy Wants End of Case to Clean Tainted Groundwater
A state appeals court will hear whether it should allow a five-year-old lawsuit trying to force Duke Energy Corp. to clean up groundwater contaminated by its North Carolina coal ash pits. The Charlotte-based electricity utility argues to the Court of Appeals on Thursday that the lawsuit should be dismissed. Duke Energy lawyers say the company […]
Duke Energy Won’t Force Neighbors to Waive All Legal Claims
Neighbors of Duke Energy Corp.’s unlined coal ash pits in North Carolina went to court after the company said their $5,000 “goodwill” payments required them to give up future health claims linked to contaminated well water, but now they’re ending the lawsuit. Lawyers representing hundreds of neighbors of the company’s coal plants dropped their lawsuit […]
NC Regulator: Can Duke Energy Charge All Coal Ash Costs?
Regulators are deciding whether to set a precedent and allow the country’s largest electric company to charge North Carolina consumers the full, multi-billion-dollar cost of cleaning up coal ash dumps. The North Carolina Utilities Commission on Monday will open hearings with Duke Energy Corp. about who should pay the cost of dealing with the toxic […]
Coal Ash is Focus in Duke Energy’s $478M Rate Increase Bid
The nation’s largest electric company is fighting to persuade regulators that North Carolina consumers should pay 15 percent more on average, including nearly $200 million a year to clean up the toxic byproducts of burning coal to generate power. Consumers, the state’s attorney general and the state’s utilities consumer advocate are digging in ahead of […]
North Carolina OKs Lined Landfill for Duke Energy Coal Ash
Environmental regulators have approved Duke Energy’s plan for a lined landfill at a coastal North Carolina power plant so coal ash can be deposited there. The state Department of Environmental Quality announced Friday the permit for the nation’s largest electric utility to operate the landfill at the Sutton Steam Plant outside Wilmington. The landfill will […]
›