A downtown Hillsborough bar is set to shutter its doors after more than a decade of business.

The Hot Tin Roof shared on Facebook Tuesday it’s planning to permanently close on Tuesday, April 30 — sharing a two-week notice for patrons and community members to visit the bar at 115 West Margaret Lane. The post thanked the people Hot Tin Roof’s owners and staff have met over “11 long and fun years.”

“It saddens us to write this, but after 11 long years – Hot Tin Roof is shutting its doors,” read Tuesday’s message on Facebook. “Thank you to all the regulars, the ‘this is our first time in’ customers, our past employees, all of our current employees, and everyone who has had made an impact on what The Hot Tin Roof ends as. We appreciate [and] love you all!!”

The business opened in 2013 under an ownership group including Mark Bateman, who continues to own and operate Hot Tin Roof today. He was later joined by Vince Tesoro and later Kim Tesoro, who took over co-ownership with Bateman. Tesoro died last July after fighting a cancer diagnosis, but her estate still co-owns the bar with Bateman, according to the News of Orange County.

Hot Tin Roof was known for attracting community members with its outdoor seating, variety of locally-themed drinks, and live music. But the business’ clientele became a hot topic in 2021 as some customers shared concerns about members of the Proud Boys — a right-wing extremist group that the Southern Poverty Law Center designates as a white supremacy and nationalist organization — frequenting the bar and wearing the group’s gear. A patron shared an open letter to INDY Week about their experience, which led it to garner widespread attention. Hot Tin Roof’s leadership later shared on its Facebook page that it would update its rules to “absolutely prohibit anyone from wearing or bringing to our business any kind of insignia, emblems, etc. which represents any kind of hate group, including specifically the Proud Boys.”

Controversy around the bar preceded the high-profile incident too, as the bar remained open during some of the early stages of the COVID-19 pandemic in 2020 compared to other businesses — in part due to its ample outdoor seating. Hot Tin Roof’s live music also led to the Town of Hillsborough updating its noise ordinance laws in 2021 to better attempt a balance between downtown businesses’ and nearby residents’ needs.

In its final days, Hot Tin Roof said it plans to have several live bands and DJs performing at the bar, and will hold its typical trivia and karaoke nights.

“Let’s make these last two weeks and absolute party,” said Tuesday’s social media post. “Come say goodbye, hello, & maybe catch Mark working behind the bar a time or two!”

Chapelboro.com does not charge subscription fees, and you can directly support our efforts in local journalism here. Want more of what you see on Chapelboro? Let us bring free local news and community information to you by signing up for our newsletter.

Related Stories
‹
The Rookery Opens on West Margaret Lane, Offering Cocktails and 'A Place to Nest'
Hillsborough welcomed a new bar to its community over the weekend — as it formally started operations in the prominent former home of another popular bar. The Rookery officially opened to customers on Friday at 115 West Margaret Lane. The business is the latest venture of B.J. Patel, who is also behind the restaurant Nomad […]
Hot Tin Roof in Hillsborough Postpones Event After COVID-19 Exposure
A popular Hillsborough business is temporarily shutting its doors and postponing an event due to a positive COVID-19 case. The Hot Tin Roof bar on West Margaret Lane shared a message with the community on Tuesday saying a member of their team was exposed to someone who recently tested positive for the coronavirus. “The safety […]
Orange County Business, Tourism Community Remembers Kim Tesoro
Kim Tesoro, a key figure in Orange County’s tourism and business community, recently died after a battle with cancer and several members of the local business community each found ways to honor her after her passing. The Tesoro family shared news of Kim’s death on July 21, saying she died on July 19 in the […]
Big Spoon Roasters Ready for Move to New Hillsborough Home
Despite being a small-batch nut butter business, the following for Big Spoon Roasters continues to get bigger and bigger. With the production room shut down for the day behind him, the company’s co-owner and president Mark Overbay walks through dozens of the shipments set to go out to grocery stores or Amazon customers. […]
Hillsborough's Wooden Nickel, Cup-A-Joe Close From COVID-19 Exposures
Two businesses in downtown Hillsborough did not open on Friday due to potential COVID-19 exposures to staff. The Wooden Nickel Public House and the Hillsborough Cup-A-Joe both alerted the community Friday morning about temporary closures. A Facebook post from the Wooden Nickel’s owners said a staff member recently experienced an exposure to a positive case […]
James Pharmacy Restaurant in Hillsborough Closing Permanently
A seafood restaurant in a historic Hillsborough building is permanently closing following a two-month hiatus due to the coronavirus. The James Pharmacy restaurant at 111 North Churton Street in Hillsborough announced Wednesday it would not be reopening. Owners Matt Fox and Dean James shared a long Facebook post with the community with the announcement. The […]
Memorial Day to Affect Local Government Services Around Orange County (2025)
The observation of Memorial Day on Monday, May 26 will affect multiple local government services around the Orange County community. Here’s a complete list of which services in which towns will be moved due to the holiday: Town of Chapel Hill Memorial Day is an official town holiday. Most town and other administrative offices will […]
Orange County Coalition Raises Alarm Over Property Value Inequities From 2025 Revaluation
A coalition of housing advocates is looking at updated Orange County property values and pointing out notable discrepancies in assessments.
Orange County Sheriff's Office: 1 Arrested, 1 At Large After Attempted Burglary
A Durham man is wanted by local law enforcement after an attempted break-in and burglary of an Orange County business, a high-speed chase and car crash during the early hours of Thursday, according to the Orange County Sheriff’s Office. A release Thursday afternoon said the office took out six felony warrants against 24-year-old Erlin Lopez […]
Suspect Pleads Guilty in Hillsborough Home Depot Employee's 2022 Death
The man charged in the death of an elderly Hillsborough Home Depot employee pled guilty on Thursday amid jury deliberations for his trial.
›