N. Carolina Lawsuit Cites Virus to Stop Touch-Screen Voting

The threat of hand-to-hand contamination from the new coronavirus while voting entered arguments in a lawsuit seeking to stop the use of touch-screen ballot-marking machines in North Carolina.

Lawyers for four North Carolina voters and the state NAACP largely cited constitutional concerns in the lawsuit announced Wednesday in asking that the equipment from the nation’s largest voting machine manufacturer be barred from future elections. About 20 of North Carolina’s 100 counties have the machines, used first in one way or another during last month’s primary elections.

But the plaintiffs also said using touch-screen machines are inherently hazardous to use during the COVID-19 crisis, because voters and poll workers are smudging screens with fingers and hands that could transmit the virus to unsuspecting people.

Cleaning the ExpressVote machines — created by Election Systems & Software and targeted in the lawsuit — after every vote, would create long lines at voting sites, the lawsuit said. An ES&S memo last month recommended poll workers should use lint-free cloths with isopropyl alcohol or prepared alcohol wipes to clean screens for at least 30 seconds to disinfect them.

“COVID-19 can survive on plastic screens,” said John Powers, an attorney for the Lawyers’ Committee for Civil Rights Under Law, which is helping represent the plaintiffs. “There’s risk if this (cleaning) doesn’t happen right each time. Both poll workers and voters can get infected.”

The litigation, which Powers said was being mailed Wednesday to court, rather than filed in person, because of health concerns, also comes as states figure how to conduct high-stakes elections this fall should the new coronavirus persist. A hint of the challenges came last week with Wisconsin’s primary, marked by long lines at precincts and a massive of influx of mail-in ballots.

Concerns over the use of touch-screen machines have intensified since hackers tried to access U.S. election systems in 2016. A study released last year by the combined National Academies of Science, Engineering and Medicine urged that elections use human-readable paper ballots that people can inspect and recount.

The safety argument provides critics of these ES&S machines, who focus largely on security and hacking concerns, another line of attack.

People shouldn’t have to choose between safety and the right to vote, said Courtney Hostetler with the group Free Speech for People and another plaintiffs’ lawyer: “Our position is that is really not a constitutional trade-off.”

Otherwise, the plaintiffs say the public can’t be confident that the names of the voters’ preferred candidates that the machine prints on the ballot will correspond with bar code data that’s also printed and tallied by a separate counting machine.

“The ExpressVote is an insecure, unreliable, and unverifiable machine that threatens the integrity of North Carolina’s elections,” the lawsuit reads.

Few if any problems related to actual machine operations were reported last month. In seven counties, including the one surrounding Charlotte, ExpressVote equipment is now the primary voting machine in election day precincts. Other counties use them for early in-person voting or for people with disabilities.

The State Board of Elections, a defendant along with county election boards, didn’t immediately provide a comment Wednesday on the lawsuit. ES&S didn’t immediately respond to an email.

Voters in other counties that use hand-marked paper ballots can feel confident that their choices will count, the lawsuit says in declaring the machines’ use violate equal protection and fair-election provisions in the North Carolina Constitution. The plaintiffs want a judge to permanently block state elections from being held with them. They could be next used in a western North Carolina Republican congressional primary runoff in late June.

‹

‘When in Doubt, Throw it Out': UNC Expert Emphasizes Importance of Cleaning Data

Have you considered how much of your personal life is stored online? From social media profiles to banking information, we entrust a lot to the digital world. But with the constant accumulation of digital files, one UNC expert says it's time to start taking digital security seriously to ensure you have easy access to your important information. 

TSA Seizes 254 Firearms at North Carolina Airports in 2021

Written by THE ASSOCIATED PRESS Transportation Security Administration officers seized 106 guns at Raleigh-Durham International Airport in 2021, nearly double the number they seized at the airport in the previous year, a news release said. Another 100 firearms were taken at the security checkpoint at Charlotte Douglas International Airport, three times the total in 2020. […]

Dominion Voting Sues Fox for $1.6B Over 2020 Election Claims

Written by COLLEEN LONG Dominion Voting Systems on Friday filed a $1.6 billion defamation lawsuit against Fox News, arguing the cable news giant falsely claimed in an effort to boost faltering ratings that the voting company had rigged the 2020 election. It’s the first defamation suit filed against a media outlet by the voting company, which […]

North Carolina, Local Government Offices in Raleigh Closed for U.S. Inauguration

Government offices are being shuttered in North Carolina’s capital as precautions against potential mayhem as Joe Biden takes his presidential oath in Washington. Municipal offices in downtown Raleigh will be closed to the public on Wednesday. Some state government and Wake County offices downtown — including the Wake courthouse — were already closed Tuesday and […]

'I Didn’t Expect the Severity To Be Worse': UNC Psychiatrist Recaps Mental Health in 2020

While the pandemic has had a substantial impact on many facets of everyday life, one of the most prominent was its impact on the general public’s mental health.

After a Year Like This, Expect a Strange New Year’s Eve

If ever a year’s end seemed like cause for celebration, 2020 might be it. Yet the coronavirus scourge that dominated the year is also looming over New Year’s festivities and forcing officials worldwide to tone them down. From New York’s Times Square to Sydney Harbor, big public blowouts are being turned into TV-only shows and digital events. […]

N.C. Judge Won't Halt Use of Touch-Screen Vote-Mark Machines

Touch-screen ballot-marking machines will remain in use in North Carolina this fall, a judge ruled in a case in which voters questioned the equipment’s accuracy and health risks during the COVID-19 pandemic. The state NAACP joined the four voters who demanded in April that the ExpressVote machines — used in roughly 20 of the state’s 100 counties […]

North Carolina Group Asks Judge to Stop Touch-Screen Voting

The North Carolina NAACP has asked a judge to bar the use of a touch-screen voting machine in several counties due to what it says are heightened risks associated with using them during the coronavirus pandemic. The request made to a Wake County judge Wednesday says the ExpressVote machines create “unique and substantial risks to […]

‘Chaos in Georgia’: Is Messy Primary a November Harbinger?

The long-standing wrangle over voting rights and election security came to a head in Georgia, where a messy primary and partisan finger-pointing offered an unsettling preview of a November contest when battleground states could face potentially record turnout. Many Democrats blamed the Republican secretary of state for hourslong lines, voting machine malfunctions, provisional ballot shortages […]

N. Carolina Lawsuit Cites Virus to Stop Touch-Screen Voting

The threat of hand-to-hand contamination from the new coronavirus while voting entered arguments in a lawsuit seeking to stop the use of touch-screen ballot-marking machines in North Carolina. Lawyers for four North Carolina voters and the state NAACP largely cited constitutional concerns in the lawsuit announced Wednesday in asking that the equipment from the nation’s […]

›