A group of UNC alumni and donors filed court documents into the lawsuit between the UNC System and a pro-Confederate group on Wednesday, arguing there was no standing for the lawsuit that led to a $2.5 million settlement.

88 alumni of the university, including 14 members of the UNC Black Pioneers, entered a brief to provide information arguing the Sons of Confederate Veterans had no claim to the Confederate monument known as Silent Sam because it was a gift to the university. The United Daughters of the Confederacy, who sold the rights to monument to the SCV, gave the monument to the university in the early 20th century. The SCV filed a lawsuit in November claiming the university system violated North Carolina’s law against the removal of objects of remembrance, with court documents showing UNC System leadership had approved of a settlement before the lawsuit was filed.

But according to an affidavit written by Cecelia Moore, which was filed alongside the UNC alumni’s brief, a deed of gift document or formal agreement between the UDC and university has not been found. In addition, when the UDC failed to raise sufficient funds to construct a monument, university president Francis Venable began his own fundraising to pay for it, even asking for donations during commencement activities during 1911.

In its argument that the SCV did not have standing to file its original lawsuit, the group of UNC alumni alleges the university had the rights to the monument, not the Confederate groups. The brief also argues even if determined as a gift, the Confederate monument had no conditions attached to its display on campus, leaving its future to the university’s disposal.

Moore served as the project manager of former chancellor Carol Folt’s task force on university history starting in 2015 before doing further research into the Confederate monument in June 2019. Many documents Moore archived, which were compiled into a UNC Libraries website, were used in the original lawsuit filed by the SCV. According to her affidavit, Moore reviewed her research when the case and which documents were used became public in November.

In addition to the 14 UNC Black Pioneers in the brief, there are many other UNC alumni of note. Author and historian Taylor Branch, former North Carolina Supreme Court Chief Justice James Exum Jr., state senator Valerie Foushee, former United States Solicitor General Walter Dellinger and former UNC women’s soccer star and World Cup champion Carla Overbeck are among the names in the motion that claims the establishing of a fund for Silent Sam’s upkeep damages the reputation of the university.

The SCV also filed a brief, defending its lawsuit by saying the transfer of rights from the UDC to the group solidifies its standing.

A court hearing to review the Sons of Confederate Veterans’ standing in the original lawsuit is scheduled for February 12.

Related Stories
‹
UNC Students File Appeal in Case Over Silent Sam Settlement
The Lawyers’ Committee for Civil Rights Under Law filed an appeal on behalf of a group of UNC students and a faculty member to intervene in the settlement between the UNC System and a pro-Confederate group. The organization filed on Tuesday in regards to the denial of its motion to intervene in the deal that […]
Daily Tar Heel Ownership Files Lawsuit Against UNC, Board of Governors Over Silent Sam Deals
The media group which owns the student newspaper The Daily Tar Heel filed a lawsuit against the University of North Carolina and the UNC System Board of Governors on Wednesday. DTH Media Corporation filed the lawsuit, alleging the settlement between the Board of Governors and the pro-Confederate group the Sons of Confederate Veterans over a […]
Civil Rights Lawyers Stake Claim in Confederate Statue Case
A national civil rights group has warned the leaders of the University of North Carolina System that it should reconsider a $2.5 million settlement involving a statue of a Confederate soldier that protesters toppled last year at the system’s flagship campus. In a letter sent to the attorney who represented the UNC Board of Governors, […]
UNC Interim Chancellor Guskiewicz Sends Letter to UNC System, Voices Concerns over Silent Sam Settlement
After a more than a week of protests by the campus community against the UNC System’s decision to settle a lawsuit with a pro-Confederate group, UNC Interim Chancellor Kevin Guskiewicz sent a letter to the system’s leadership outlining concerns over the decision. Guskiewicz, who shared the letter in a message to the campus community on […]
UNC Faculty Condemn System's Settlement with Pro-Confederate Group in Resolution
Faculty members of UNC voiced their opposition to a settlement by the UNC System with a pro-Confederate group over the statue known as Silent Sam. At its monthly meeting on Friday, the UNC Faculty Council passed a resolution criticizing the decision to create a $2.5 million trust fund and cede possession of the Confederate monument […]
UNC Students Protest System's Settlement over Silent Sam
The spot where Silent Sam once stood on McCorkle Place is now covered with fallen leaves, making it impossible to tell exactly where the Confederate statue was before being toppled in 2018. Protesters walked over it on their way to the steps of South Building as part of a demonstration to speak out against the […]
Court Docs: UNC System Prepared Silent Sam Settlement Before Lawsuit Was Filed
The UNC System announced Wednesday November 27 it was settling a lawsuit the Sons of Confederate Veterans had filed against it. But according to court documents, the settlement of a $2.5 million trust fund and possession of the Confederate monument known as Silent Sam was determined before the lawsuit was even filed. Court documents accessed […]
Orange County Judge: SCV Have 45 Days to Return 'Silent Sam' to UNC
A judge imposed a 45-day deadline on the Sons of Confederate Veterans to return the Silent Sam statue to the University of North Carolina. Orange County Superior Court Judge Allen Baddour also ruled that the group must return the remaining balance of a $2.5 million trust fund that the university’s board of governors set up […]
Confederate Group Lawsuit, Silent Sam Settlement Dismissed in Court
An Orange County judge has dismissed the lawsuit filed by the Sons of Confederate Veterans against the UNC System, voiding the $2.5 million payment to the pro-Confederate group and the transfer of property of the Silent Sam monument. After hearing arguments from both original parties, as well as two groups who filed amicus briefs arguing […]
Group of UNC Alumni Say Pro-Confederate Group Had No Standing in Silent Sam Lawsuit
A group of UNC alumni and donors filed court documents into the lawsuit between the UNC System and a pro-Confederate group on Wednesday, arguing there was no standing for the lawsuit that led to a $2.5 million settlement. 88 alumni of the university, including 14 members of the UNC Black Pioneers, entered a brief to […]
›