What do you hate more?
The presidential election campaign?
Or the furor over HB2?
The good news is that one will be over in a few weeks. The bad news is that the other won’t.
On November 8 the election campaigning ends. The heavy doses of drug-like campaign ads and cable news coverage the mean-spirited, misleading, and malicious barrages fired by and at the candidates will halt.
But HB2 will still be with us, tearing us asunder, holding our state up to ridicule.
Unnecessarily, because reasonable people could have worked out a common-sense solution that recognized, respectfully and practically, the needs and aspirations of transgender people, while protecting the public from danger and abuse.
But politics gets in the way.
The governor’s re-election campaign ads tout HB2 as necessary protection for children in public bathrooms who could be threatened by adults of the opposite sex.
Meanwhile, the Democratic challenger’s campaign energizes core supporters by calling for the immediate and unconditional repeal of HB2, exploiting its growing unpopularity in the sports and business communities.
Thus, a compromise solution would not serve the campaigns of either candidate.
Each side blames the other for the mess HB2 has created.
Conservative religious and “traditional values” groups are an important part of the Republican coalition in North Carolina. They pushed for HB2 and resist its repeal.
But there are other important religions in North Carolina: sports and business.
The actions by the National Basketball Association (NBA), National Collegiate Athletic Association (NCAA) and the Atlantic Coast Conference (ACC) to move important sports contests out of North Carolina sparked a new fire of concern about HB2.
UNC President Margaret Spellings has been cautious and careful not to criticize HB2 directly. “We are surprised and disappointed by the NCAA’s decision and regret the impact it will have on North Carolina’s student-athletes, coaches, athletic staffs, fans, and the North Carolina communities previously chosen to host these championship events.” She says,. “We remain caught in the middle”
On the other hand, a representative of a private college supported the ACC and NCAA. Davidson’s athletic director Jim Murphy wrote, “Davidson College has opposed the plainly discriminatory bill known as HB2 since the day it was hastily signed into law. The law harms many and protects no one….”
Meanwhile, other North Carolinians are counting the money that will not come to North Carolina because of HB2 and actions like those of the NCAA and ACC.
A business recruiter told me recently that his community had lost several large business prospects who told him they could no longer consider North Carolina because of HB2. He said, “We are just no longer on their list.”
After November’s election is over, maybe common sense can prevail, and HB2 can be buried respectfully. But getting North Carolina back on the lists of sports events and businesses looking for good locations will not happen quickly.
The ghost of HB2 will haunt us for a long time.
Related Stories
‹

Former North Carolina Gov. McCrory Enters U.S. Senate RaceWritten by GARY D. ROBERTSON Former Republican Gov. Pat McCrory on Wednesday announced he’ll run for the U.S. Senate in North Carolina, shaking up the calculus in the expanding field to succeed retiring Sen. Richard Burr with the entrance of a veteran of statewide politics. McCrory, who served as governor for four years through 2016, revealed […]
![]()
Carrboro Mayor Condemns Bill Aiming to Prevent Trans Students in SportsThe “Save Women’s Sports Act” or House Bill 538 introduced in the North Carolina General Assembly last week would prevent trans youth and women from competing in sports which do not align to the gender on their birth certificate. North Carolina is the 30th state to introduce the bill.
![]()
Carrboro, Chapel Hill Governments Pass Anti-Discrimination OrdinancesIn second and third consecutive nights, local governments in Orange County unanimously passed new ordinances that prohibit discrimination in employment and places of accommodation. Both the Carrboro Town Council and the Chapel Hill Town Council adopted a set of ordinances that now prevent businesses or organizations from denying people services and jobs purely because of […]
![]()
Settlement Expands Transgender Restroom Rights in N CarolinaA federal judge approved a legal settlement Tuesday affirming transgender people’s right to use restrooms matching their gender identity in many North Carolina public buildings. The consent decree between the state’s Democratic governor and transgender plaintiffs covers numerous state-owned buildings including facilities run by executive branch agencies that oversee the environment, transportation and Medicaid, among […]
![]()
NC 'Bathroom Bill' Sponsor Wins GOP Redo of Tainted ElectionNorth Carolina’s most infamous political story lines of recent years are merging into a congressional race this summer that pits the architect of the state’s “bathroom bill” against a Democrat who was granted an electoral do-over after evidence of ballot fraud tainted his prior opponent’s campaign. State Sen. Dan Bishop topped nine other Republican candidates […]
![]()
Bills Opposing "Conversion Therapy," HB2 Remnants FiledGay rights advocates and their supporters at the legislature said Thursday that expanding antidiscrimination laws and repealing remnants of the North Carolina “bathroom bill” will make clear that LGBT people in the state aren’t second-class citizens. Democratic lawmakers unveiled three new pieces of House legislation, one of which also would prohibit so-called “conversion therapy” for minors. It […]
![]()
Ban on North Carolina Trips Cramps NY State College SwimmersA ban on New York state-funded travel to North Carolina is complicating matters for state college swimmers heading south for an NCAA championship. Democratic Gov. Andrew Cuomo signed an executive order in 2016 banning non-essential state-funded travel to North Carolina after lawmakers there voided a Charlotte ordinance that would have enabled transgender people to use […]
![]()
NC's LGBTQ Protections Rank Low in Human Rights Campaign's Annual IndexThe Human Rights Campaign, or HRC, has released their 5th annual State Equity Index, a report which categorizes states by how well LGBTQ citizens are protected through legislation. Out of the four categories, North Carolina falls into the lowest, which is “High Priority to Achieve Basic Equality.” State Legislative Director for HRC Cathryn Oakley says […]
![]()
Judge Mulls Letting Bathroom Bill Fight ProceedA federal judge needs time to consider whether transgender plaintiffs can proceed with a lawsuit challenging a North Carolina law that replaced the state’s “bathroom bill.” U.S. District Judge Thomas Schroeder heard arguments Monday over a request by Republican lawmakers to dismiss the lawsuit. He said at the end of the hearing that he would […]
![]()
Group Won’t Endorse Lawmakers Who Voted for HB 2 ReplacementNorth Carolina’s leading gay rights group says it won’t endorse in this year’s General Assembly elections incumbents who voted for legislation last year partially repealing the “bathroom bill.” Equality North Carolina announced its decision Tuesday, two weeks before primaries. It could affect dozens of legislators, especially Democrats historically more likely to receive backing. Equality NC […]
›