Officials from the United States Department of Housing and Urban Development visited Chapel Hill last week after the town’s public housing was graded at 52 out of 100 possible points during a semiannual evaluation.
That score left Chapel Hill in the “Troubled Performer” category of HUD rankings and caused concern among town staff and elected officials.
During the visit last week, it was discovered that a “clerical error” was a “major component” of the low ranking, according to a follow-up email from town manager Roger Stancil to the Chapel Hill Town Council.
The error came from “staff entering one piece of key information in an incorrect box on the reporting form used in early reporting with unaudited numbers.” Stancil wrote that staff would submit the updated correct information and believed that would place the town back into better federal standing.
The clerical error resulted in the town scoring a 2 out of a possible 25 points in the financial section of the score. Staff wrote that the low score was an anomaly, pointing to the previous evaluation where the town scored a perfect 25 out of 25. The town will be implementing several steps to prevent this error in the future, the email said, including independent verification of data input and a calculation prior to the final report submittal to forecast the HUD score.
Stancil wrote when answering a question from a council member asking about the town’s historic performance on these evaluations that the town received a Substandard Performer rating in 2005, a Troubled Performer status in 2013 that was also attributed to a data entry error, and when the town received a Substandard Performer rating in 2014.
The town submitted a recovery plan to HUD officials. Stancil wrote that he believed the town would return to the Standard or High Performer level.
The Town Council is also scheduled to receive a consultant’s report on the town’s Public Housing Master Plan at a meeting on May 2.
Related Stories
‹

Chapel Hill Combating 'Rumors' During HUD VisitOfficials from the United States Department on Housing and Urban Development are scheduled to visit Chapel Hill on Wednesday. This comes after the town graded out at 52 out of 100 possible points during a semiannual evaluation of the town’s public housing by the federal agency in late 2017. The score left Chapel Hill in […]

2 Chapel Hill Affordable Housing Projects Given Big Financial BoostsTwo Chapel Hill affordable housing projects recently earned substantial financial help: one through a donation, another through a tax credit. Habitat for Humanity of Orange County announced Monday its Weavers Grove project is receiving a $1 million donation from Oak Foundation — an international organization with its U.S. headquarters in Chapel Hill. The group shares […]

Chapel Hill's Public Housing Plan: Improve Existing UnitsChapel Hill’s public housing program presented its updated master plan during the town council’s meeting on April 10. It’s part of Chapel Hill’s larger strategic plan for improving housing options across all income levels. Chapel Hill’s public housing population makes up about two percent of the town’s residents. But out of the 336 units available, […]
![]()
Congressman Price Holds Listening Session in Chapel HillRemarks made by US Representative David Price on the state of the nation drew thunderous applause during a community listening session held in the auditorium of East Chapel Hill High School. “It’s a time that, I think it’s fair to say, none of us have ever experienced in our country’s history — a time of […]
![]()
The 5:00 News - Local Budget Priorities, Gov. Stein's Popularity, Drake Powell to NBAThe Hill's Andrew Stuckey presents the afternoon news. Included in this edition of the news we hear a story on local governments weighing budget priorities during a tough cycle augmented by massive federal spending cuts. In education news, we hear of a principal hire for Seawell Elementary School, a big gift for the UNC theatre department, and a student earning an academic honor. We hear from Public Policy Polling's Tom Jenson on Governor Josh Stein's popularity, and more. In sports, Drake Powell declares for the NBA draft, the Diamond Heels host a student home run derby, and more.

Chapel Hill Cuts Ribbon, Opens Fully Inclusive Playground at Community Center ParkChapel Hill leaders, parks and recreation staff, and families in the disability community gathered to open the new playground on Wednesday.
![]()
The Morning News: Inclusive Playground, Proposed Sports Complex, Diamond Heels on the RoadThe Hill’s Andrew Stuckey fills in for Aaron Keck, presenting the morning news. In this edition of the news, we learn of a Carrboro man's arrest in Chatham County on charges of kidnapping and human trafficking involving a child. We hear about the ribbon-cutting on an inclusive playground in Chapel Hill. We hear a story on a proposed 600,000 sq. foot youth sports complex in Pittsboro, and more. In sports, the Diamond Heels hit the road for a three game series at Virginia Tech, a tar heels competes in the gymnastics national tournament, and more.
![]()
The Morning News: Carjacking Suspect Caught, Children's Museum of NC, Gymnastics ChampionshipsThe Hill’s Andrew Stuckey fills in for Aaron Keck, presenting the morning news. In this edition of the news, we learn of a juvenile suspect being apprehended in connection with two recent carjackings. We hear from Chair of the Orange County Commissioners on the advantages of the land they purchased for the county's future Crisis Diversion Facility. We also hear from Kidzu on their rebrand as the North Carolina Children's Museum. In sports, UNC gymnast Kaya Forbes competes for a national title this evening at the NCAA Championships in Ft. Worth, and more.
![]()
The Morning News: Land for Crisis Diversion Facility, New Birthing Center, Baseball WinsThe Hill’s Andrew Stuckey fills in for Aaron Keck, presenting the morning news. In this edition of the news we learn of the Orange County Commissioners going forward with the purchase of land for a crises diversion facility. We hear a story on a recently opened birthing center in Chapel Hill, and more. In sports, the Diamond Heels get a big win as Scott Forbes says they are learning to do the things that will be important in the post season. Softball gets a win, a football player enters the transfer portal, and more.

Continuing the Legacy: A New Birth Center Opens in Chapel Hill, Honoring Its PredecessorA new birth center recently opened its doors to the Triangle community, offering an alternative to hospital births.
›
“staff entering information”
It is really amazing to consider with the technology available today that this data is being provided manually by cities and then keyed into some other system BY HAND!
HUD deserves a poor score for being so out-dated that they are still using actual paper for their paperwork.