CARRBORO – A week after the state Court of Appeals upheld Chapel Hill’s ability to enforce its towing laws, a Carrboro resident has filed a complaint against Barnes Towing for violating the Town Code.
Among the rules that Josh Arenth, the man in question, is accusing Barnes Towing of violating is exceeding the maximum $100 fine and not accepting payment by credit or debit card. Arenth says his car was towed from the Carr Mill Mall parking lot after he went to a nearby shop not served by the lot.
Carrboro Mayor Mark Chilton says multiple complaints have been filed against multiple towing companies in Carrboro, but town officials did not know to what authority they had to respond.
“With the recent decision in George’s Towing v. Town of Chapel Hill, I think it’s clear that we do have the power to act,” Chilton said.
The Superior Court ruled that Chapel Hill’s towing regulations, including maximum fines, easily accessible lots and acceptance of credit and debit cards, were unconstitutional. This made towns like Carrboro unsure of what enforceable power they had until the Court of Appeals’ overruling decision.
To act upon Town Code violations by towing companies, Mayor Chilton says the town must first receive a complaint from a citizen.
“When we receive complaints, we’re definitely taking them seriously and investigating,” Chilton said.
Barnes Towing released a statement saying they do not violate the Town Code and they are unaware of Arenth’s case.
Related Stories
‹
Top Stories of 2025: Flash Flooding From Tropical Storm Chantal Damages Region, Changes LivesPerhaps no singular event influenced the Orange County community's experience in 2025 more than Tropical Storm Chantal's floods in July.
'So Much Fun': Community's First 'Cardboard War' Brings Out Creativity and WhimsyThe Carrboro Town Commons was the site of a "cardboard war" on Saturday, which was created to spur whimsy and creativity among the community.
![]()
Arts in Uncertain Times - Dec. 12, 2025The Hill's Andrew Stuckey speaks with North Carolina Poet Laureate Jakie Shelton Green, Carrboro Town Council Member Fred Joiner, and Executive Director of Orange County Arts Katie Murray on Friday, December 12. They discuss the challenges facing the arts community both generally and locally. They also discuss the role of arts in times of political division. They discuss the economic, social, and personal impact of having art in non-traditional spaces. They look ahead to 2026, and more.
![]()
Checking the Area Housing Inventory - Dec. 11, 2025The Hill's Andrew Stuckey speaks with Vice President of Advocacy for the Chamber For a Greater Chapel Hill-Carrboro Ian Scott, Policy Director for Carolina Forward and Chapel Hill Town Council Member Theodore Nollert, and President of the Orange and Chatham County Association of Realters Randy Voller. They discussed the current housing inventory in the Chapel Hill area, including how much and what type of housing is still missing, and what tools the community has to encourage more housing. They also discussed what they hope to see different in the area's housing market in 2026, and more.
![]()
Carrboro: Council Meeting, Holiday Events, Braxton Foushee Day of ServiceCarrboro Mayor Barbara Foushee spoke with 97.9 The Hill's Andrew Stuckey on Friday, December 5, discussing town news and events. She outlined the most recent Carrboro Town Council meeting in which the council chose a new Mayor Pro Tem, had a resolution recognizing outgoing council member Randi Haven-O'Donnell, and swore in newly elected members. She also talked about the Carrboro tree lighting this weekend, the Chapel Hill-Carrboro Holiday Parade, and more.
'Who Are We Targeting?': Unpacking and Examining Impacts of ICE's N.C. OperationsThe Orange County community felt the impact of federal immigration officers’ presence. Weeks later, people are still unpacking their emotions.
Rep. Allen Buansi Seeks Third Term in N.C. House to Represent Chapel Hill, CarrboroNorth Carolina District 56 Rep. Allen Buansi is seeking a third full term in the state house, announcing he will run for re-election in 2026.
Thanksgiving Holiday to Affect Local Government Services in Orange County (2025)Thanksgiving will fall on Thursday, November 27 this year, and the holiday will affect several local government services around the Orange County community. Here’s a rundown of what residents can expect: Town of Chapel Hill Thursday, November 27 and Friday, November 28 are both town holidays. Residential trash collection will not be affected. However, there […]
Chapel Hill-Carrboro Icons Howard and Lillian Lee, Braxton Foushee Granted Statewide HonorThree groundbreaking Black local leaders saw their years of service awarded by being inducted into the Order of The Long Leaf Pine
Town Of Carrboro Selects John Fussa As New Planning DirectorThe Town of Carrboro announced it has selected a new planning director. John Fussa will take up the role in Dec. 2025.
›
