The Town Council is pondering how bed and breakfasts might change the character of Chapel Hill’s historic neighborhoods.

In some tourist towns like Asheville, bed and breakfasts have been hailed as a way to revitalize historic neighborhoods, but Mayor Mark Kleinschmidt said he’s not convinced that’s needed in Chapel Hill.

“Somebody earlier tonight said, ‘What problem is this solving?’, and I think for many of our neighborhoods it’s not solving any problem. It’s just potentially creating them,” said Kleinschmidt.

The council heard from residents on the issue Monday night. Many, including Boundary Street homeowner Sally Sather, were opposed to the concept.

“No one I have talked to in my neighborhood is in favor of allowing bed and breakfasts to start buying up our houses,” said Sather. “Allowing this kind of creeping commercialism would be a terrible precedent for this council to set.”

Town planners told the council they don’t recommend wide-spread permitting of B&Bs either, but the council could consider allowing some neighborhoods to opt in.

One example might be the Cameron-McCauley Historic District, where long-time residents say student rentals have taken over, destabilizing the neighborhood. Kurt Ribisl is the president of the Westside Neighborhood Association. He told the council new bed and breakfasts sound better than more of what his neighbors call “student-stuffers.”

“Between having a rental property or a B&B, people would think that a B&B would be a more desirable option in our neighborhood,” said Ribisl.

Laurie Paolicelli, head of the Orange County Community Relations and Tourism Department, warned the council the growth of short-term rentals like Airbnb means Chapel Hill leaders may have missed the opportunity to oversee the process.

“If you look at Airbnb and you google 27514 or 27516, there are so many options that I fear we’re already in the B&B business, but not regulated and not in a healthy way and that really concerns me,” said Paolicelli.

The question of whether to allow bed and breakfasts in Chapel Hill has been debated off and on since 1984. The B&B debate will continue October 26.

Related Stories
‹
Chapel Hill Passes Short-Term Rentals Resolution
At Wednesday’s Chapel Hill Town Council meeting, a resolution was unanimously passed to help regulate short-term rentals and ensure safety for property owners.
Chapel Hill to Regulate Short-Term Rentals, Airbnbs in Community
Short-Term Rentals, like those of Airbnb, have come under scrutiny by local officials and Chapel Hill residents as the industry continues to grow and the current market is left mostly unregulated.
Chapel Hill Mayor Jess Anderson Announces 2025 Re-Election Campaign
Chapel Hill Mayor Jess Anderson will run for a second term this summer and fall, as she announced Thursday on 97.9 The Hill.
Wes McMahon Announces Candidacy for Chapel Hill Town Council
Wes McMahon, a member of the Town of Chapel Hill Planning Commission, announced his candidacy for Town Council on Thursday afternoon. 
Chapel Hill Town Council Approves Application for Affordable Senior Housing Community at Homestead Road
The Town of Chapel Hill recently approved a zoning application for a proposed senior housing community located along Homestead Road.
With Federal Funding Losses and Revaluation, Orange County's Governments Weigh Difficult Tax Rate and Budget Choices
The annual budgeting process is typically an exhaustive one for Orange County’s local governments and staff – but this year, it may be even more so
Chapel Hill: Balancing Budget Shortfall with Adjusted Property Taxes + Opening An Inclusive Playground
Chapel Hill Mayor Jess Anderson joins 97.9 The Hill News Director Brighton McConnell in-studio on Thursday, April 17.
Local Government Meetings: April 14-18, 2025
This week in local government: a budget vote for Chapel Hill-Carrboro schools and a crisis diversion facility for Orange County.
Chapel Hill Council Approves 300+ New Apartments, Retail Space on S. Elliott Road
The Chapel Hill Town Council approved a conditional zoning request for 200 South Elliott Road, paving the way for a new apartment community.
Chapel Hill Shares Latest Pond Removal, Construction Timeline for Legion Road Housing and Park Project
The Town of Chapel Hill is beginning early stages to drain and remove both the pond and dam at its property off Legion Road.
›