The Chapel Hill – Carrboro City School System Board of Education has selected new leadership.
Three new members were elected to the Chapel Hill – Carrboro City School Board on November 3, and they have already made their presence felt.
The three newly-elected board members – Rani Dasi, Pat Heinrich and Margaret Samuels – joined together and elected James Barrett as the new chair of the Board of Education.
The three new members, along with Barrett, outnumbered the other three board members who supported Andrew Davidson for chair. Davidson has served as vice chair for the past year under chair Mike Kelley, who chose to not seek re-election.
Board member Michelle Brownstein said at the board meeting last Thursday that this board found itself in unchartered waters.
“The seven of us find ourselves in an unprecedented situation,” she said. “The chair seat is vacant, due to retirement, and three of us have just been sworn in and are working very hard to successfully jump on this moving bus.
“The other four completely empathize with this situation. Turns out we also are on a steep learning curve, because we’re trying to figure out what it takes to be a good board with three new board members. And a functional board.”
Brownstein, who has served as board chair in the past, spoke in favor of Davidson for chair following his tenure as vice chair, saying he is most prepared for the role.
“The closest thing we have is an opportunity to apprentice as vice chair,” she said. “During that year, there is a mentoring that occurs between the chair and the vice chair and that is priceless.
“Just as none of us realizes what truly is involved in being an effective school board member until we actually spend time serving as one, no one knows what it really means to be an effective board chair until you actually serve as one.”
Brownstein warned of the ramifications of heading in a different direction.
“I want to caution us to avoid tearing down something of value until we are certain we have something of value to replace it with,” she said. “I’m referring specifically to determining our chair.
“First, serving as board chair is very difficult. I’m speaking from personal experience, something no one else who is sitting here can do.”
There was no further discussion following Brownstein’s comments before calling for a vote.
Davidson, Brownstein and Annetta Streater – the only incumbent re-elected to the board – voted for Davidson as chair but were outvoted.
Following the election of the chair, Streater, who has served on the board since 2006, was unanimously elected as vice chair.
Related Stories
‹

'How Are We Engaging in Schools?' Orange County Shares Survey ResultsIn its first meeting of the year, the Orange County Schools Board of Education discussed results from a survey that aimed to better understand issues facing parents and students.

CHCCS School Board Considers Vote on Plan B, Hybrid Learning ModelThe Chapel Hill-Carrboro City Schools Board of Education will be holding a virtual meeting tonight to discuss the district’s potential move into a hybrid learning model.
![]()
Candidate Intros: Chapel Hill and Carrboro City Schools Board of Education (4 Seats)Hear from the five candidates running for Chapel Hill and Carrboro City Board of Education: Rani Dasi: https://chapelboroaudio.s3.amazonaws.com/2019/CANDIDATE%20INTROS/Dasi%20FINAL.mp3 Andrew Davidson: https://chapelboroaudio.s3.amazonaws.com/2019/CANDIDATE%20INTROS/Davidson%20FINAL.mp3 Jillian La Serna: https://chapelboroaudio.s3.amazonaws.com/2019/CANDIDATE%20INTROS/La%20Serna%20FINAL.mp3 Ashton Powell: https://chapelboroaudio.s3.amazonaws.com/2019/CANDIDATE%20INTROS/Powell%20FINAL.mp3 Deon Temne: https://chapelboroaudio.s3.amazonaws.com/2019/CANDIDATE%20INTROS/Temne%20FINAL.mp3
![]()
General Assembly Confirms 3 Cooper Education Board PicksThe North Carolina General Assembly has confirmed three of Gov. Roy Cooper’s recent appointments to the State Board of Education, one year after Republican legislators voted against two of his choices. House and Senate members meeting in a rare joint floor session on Wednesday voted 140-8 to approve the appointments of J.B. Buxton of Raleigh, […]
![]()
Orange County Schools Surprisingly Shake Up Board LeadershipThe atmosphere was tense at times on Monday night during the meeting of the Orange County Schools Board of Education. Several votes occurred in succession, all falling along the same 4-3 result. The board was set to fill a leadership role after Sarah Smylie said that she would be vacating the vice chair role, while […]
![]()
N Carolina Board of Education Chair Announces ResignationThe North Carolina Board of Education chair has announced he’s resigning early, citing issues with other members having to serve past their terms. News outlets report 79-year-old Bill Cobey submitted his resignation Thursday. Cobey’s term on the board would have ended in March. His resignation goes into effect after a Sept. 6 board meeting where […]
![]()
Board of Education Candidates Respond to Position Questions at ForumA forum was held last Monday for the Chapel Hill and Carrboro School Board of Education candidates to answer questions about their positions on issues regarding Chapel Hill and Carrboro schools. WCHL’s Aaron Keck moderated the forum. The candidates present at the forum were James Barrett, Joal Hall Broun, Calvin Deutschbein, Amy Fowler, Kim Talikoff […]
![]()
Board of Education Bars Sixth-Grade Students in Chapel Hill and Carrboro from Sports TeamsThe Chapel Hill-Carrboro City Schools Board of Education is putting sixth-grade students on the bench after a debate on whether they should be allowed to join middle school sports teams. That debate ended last Monday with board members endorsing a recommendation to raise the grade level at which students are allowed to participate in interscholastic […]
![]()
Revised Living Wage Policy Approved by Chapel Hill-Carrboro City SchoolsThe Board of Education for Chapel Hill-Carrboro City Schools unanimously approved a revised living wage policy for full-time employees and contractors on January 19. The policy aims to keep district salaries congruent with living wage estimates from Orange County Living Wage, a non-profit group that encourages voluntary payroll compliance from employers. Those estimates came from […]
![]()
Funding Gap in CHCCS Board Plans for New ConstructionCHCCS assistant superintendent for support services Todd LoFrese talked about ideas to fill a funding gap for the new construction at Lincoln Center and Chapel Hill High School at the school board meeting last Thursday. The board authorized a budget of almost $1.4 million for both projects at a previous meeting but have since exhausted […]
›
Comments on Chapelboro are moderated according to our Community Guidelines